A new home in Hillsborough County carried a much higher median sale price than a resale in September 2026. The simple conclusion would be that builders are charging far more for the same house. The underlying numbers say the comparison is not that simple.
The price gap was 27.6 percent
According to an October 27 analysis of Stellar MLS closed sales, the median new-construction sale in Hillsborough County was $484,990 in September. The median resale was $380,000. That works out to a 27.6 percent difference.
But the median new home was also much larger: 2,394 square feet compared with 1,714 square feet for the median resale. On a price-per-square-foot basis, the order flipped. New construction had a median of $216 per square foot, while resales were at $223.
That does not make every new home a bargain. It shows why two countywide medians cannot tell you which individual property is the better value.
New-home sales were down
From January through September, Hillsborough recorded 1,692 new-construction closings, down 21.9 percent from 2,166 during the same period in 2025. Resale closings increased 0.9 percent to 12,649.
New homes made up 11.8 percent of all closed sales during those nine months, compared with 14.7 percent a year earlier. In September alone, 172 of 1,425 closings were new construction.
The data covers Hillsborough County, not Pasco County communities such as Wesley Chapel, Land O' Lakes, or Zephyrhills. It also does not break the county total into Tampa, Brandon, Riverview, Wimauma, Plant City, or other local submarkets. Buyers should not apply the county median to one neighborhood without checking nearby sales.
List price is only part of a builder deal
The analysis found that September new homes took a median 63 days on market, compared with 39 days for resales. New homes closed at 98.0 percent of original list price, while resales closed at 95.6 percent.
That still does not capture every concession. Builders may offer money toward closing costs, a temporary or permanent rate buydown, lot premiums, design-center credits, or appliance packages. Some incentives require the buyer to use the builder's preferred lender or title company.
Compare the full transaction, not just the advertised payment. Ask for the base price, lot premium, structural options, design upgrades, lender fees, rate assumptions, closing-cost credit, HOA or CDD costs, taxes, insurance, and estimated completion date in writing.
A fair comparison uses similar homes
Put a new four-bedroom home next to resales with similar square footage, location, school assignment, lot size, and monthly ownership costs. Then account for likely repair needs and the builder warranty. A smaller 1990s resale and a larger new home may both be good options, but the countywide median price gap alone cannot settle the choice.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!