# Is the Lowest Mortgage Rate Always the Best Deal?

By Brandon Peterson (@brandonpeterson) · Published 2026-11-21

Canonical: https://voce.com/@brandonpeterson/lowest-mortgage-rate-always-best-deal-hr26r9

---

# Is the Lowest Mortgage Rate Always the Best Deal? How Twin Cities Buyers Find the Best Mortgage Terms

The lowest rate is not always the cheapest loan. What really matters is the total cost of the loan for as long as you will actually keep it. That includes points, closing costs and mortgage insurance, and it depends on your credit, your down payment and how long you plan to stay in the home. The right loan program for your situation will often save you more than a slightly lower rate.

I have been helping Minnesota families with mortgages since 2008, and the most expensive mistake I see is not a bad rate. It is a good looking rate attached to the wrong loan.

## Why rate is not the only number that matters

A rate quote by itself tells you very little. Two lenders can quote the same rate and charge very different amounts to get it. One may build in points, another may have higher lender fees, and a third may put you in a program with more expensive mortgage insurance. When you compare offers, look at these together:

-   **The rate and what it costs to get it.** Points show up in Section A of your Loan Estimate.
    
-   **Total closing costs and cash to close.** This is the money that leaves your bank account.
    
-   **Mortgage insurance.** It can add more to your payment than a small rate difference ever will.
    
-   **How long you will keep the loan.** Five years, two years or thirty years changes which offer wins.
    

## What does it mean to buy down your rate with points?

A point, also called a discount point, is a fee you pay at closing to get a lower interest rate. One point equals 1% of your loan amount. On a $475,000 loan, one point costs $4,750. How much a point lowers your rate changes with the market, so there is no fixed trade.

Points are not good or bad on their own. They are a trade. You pay cash today in exchange for a smaller payment every month. The only question is whether you will keep the loan long enough to get that cash back.

## How do I know if paying points makes sense?

Do the break even math. Divide what the points cost by how much they lower your monthly payment. The answer is the number of months it takes to earn your money back.

-   If you will keep the loan well past the break even point, points can be a smart move.
    
-   If you might sell, move or refinance before then, you are paying for savings you will never collect.
    

Most buyers do not keep the same mortgage for thirty years. People move for work, grow their families or refinance when rates drop. That is why I always ask how long you really expect to be in the home before we talk about points.

## A real example, a Blaine buyer and the points that did not pay off

A client came to me as a referral from his financial planner. His job was bringing him to Minnesota for no more than 24 months, and he was buying a home in Blaine to live in while he was here. At the end of the assignment he would move back to Texas and sell.

He already had an offer from an online lender, and on the surface it looked great. The rate was noticeably below what most lenders were quoting. When I went through his Loan Estimate, the reason was clear. He was paying discount points up front to buy that rate down.

Here is roughly how the numbers worked. (These figures are rounded and simplified to show the math. They are not his exact numbers or a current rate quote.)

-   Loan amount of about $475,000
    
-   Cost of 3 points, about $14,250, paid at closing
    
-   Rate reduction of about 0.625%
    
-   Monthly payment savings of about $193
    
-   Break even of $14,250 divided by $193, which is about 74 months, or more than 6 years
    

He planned to own the home for 24 months at most. In that time the lower payment would save him about $4,600. He would have paid $14,250 to get it. Even after counting the little bit of extra principal a lower rate pays down, he was on track to lose more than $8,000 on the points alone.

He was not doing anything wrong. He was doing what most people do, which is shop for the lowest rate. Nobody had asked him how long he would be here.

## How I restructured the loan

Once I understood his whole situation, the answer was simple. We removed the points and priced his loan at a rate that did not require any up front buydown. For someone keeping a loan for two years, a slightly higher rate with lower closing costs is almost always the better deal. The result:

-   Thousands of dollars less cash needed at closing
    
-   A monthly payment that was only slightly higher
    
-   A lower total cost for the time he would actually own the home
    
-   More cash in the bank for his move back to Texas
    

His financial planner was happy, and more importantly, he understood exactly why the cheaper looking offer was actually the more expensive one.

## Can an FHA loan cost more even with a lower rate?

Yes. FHA rates are often lower than conventional rates, which surprises a lot of buyers. The catch is mortgage insurance. FHA loans charge an upfront mortgage insurance premium of 1.75% of the loan amount, usually added to the loan, plus an annual premium that is 0.55% for most borrowers and paid monthly. If you put down less than 10%, that monthly premium stays for the life of the loan unless you refinance out of it.

Conventional loans with less than 20% down have private mortgage insurance instead. It has no upfront premium, it can be removed once you build enough equity, and with a strong credit score it is often cheaper than FHA mortgage insurance.

So a buyer with good credit might see a lower FHA rate and assume FHA is the better choice. Once you add the upfront premium and the monthly mortgage insurance, the conventional loan can easily win on total cost.

## Can a conventional loan cost more than FHA?

It can, and credit score is usually the reason. Conventional pricing and private mortgage insurance are both heavily based on credit score. With a lower score and a small down payment, a conventional loan can carry a higher rate and much more expensive mortgage insurance. FHA pricing is much less sensitive to credit score.

For some buyers with scores in the lower range, FHA ends up with a lower total payment even after its mortgage insurance. There is no one answer for everyone. The right program depends on your credit score, down payment, debts, the property and how long you will keep the loan. The only way to know is to price both side by side for your exact situation.

## Why working with an experienced lender matters

Online rate quotes are built to get your attention. They often assume perfect credit, a large down payment and points you may not have noticed. They also cannot ask the questions that change the answer, like whether you are moving in two years or planning to stay for twenty.

When you work with me, I:

-   Compare conventional, FHA, VA, USDA and Minnesota Housing options side by side when they fit your situation
    
-   Show you what the rate costs, not just what the rate is
    
-   Run the break even math on any points so you can decide with real numbers
    
-   Look at the total cost for the time you actually plan to keep the loan
    
-   Explain the tradeoffs in plain language so you can make the call
    

My goal is not to win on a headline rate. It is to put you in the loan that costs you the least and fits your plans.

## Frequently asked questions

?Frequently Asked Questions5 questions

1Is the lowest mortgage rate always the best option?

No. A lower rate often comes with points or higher fees. The best option is the one with the lowest total cost for the time you plan to keep the loan.

2How much does one point cost?

One point is 1% of the loan amount. On a $300,000 loan, one point is $3,000.

3When does paying points make sense?

When you expect to keep the loan longer than the break even period. If you might move or refinance sooner, paying points usually costs you money.

4Is FHA mortgage insurance more expensive than conventional PMI?

It depends on your credit and down payment. FHA charges an upfront premium plus a monthly premium that often lasts for the life of the loan. With strong credit, conventional PMI is often cheaper and can be removed later.

5How should I compare two Loan Estimates?

Compare the rate, the points and lender fees in Section A, total closing costs, cash to close and the monthly mortgage insurance. Then think about how long you will actually keep the loan.

## Want a second set of eyes on your offer?

If you already have a quote from another lender, send it to me. I will go through it line by line, show you what the rate is really costing you and tell you honestly whether I can do better. Sometimes the best thing I can do is confirm you already have a good deal.

Call or text Brandon Peterson at 612-964-1371.

* * *

Brandon Peterson NMLS #302002 | Granite Bank NMLS# 405434, Equal Housing Lender, 11660 Theatre Drive N. Champlin, MN 55316. This is not a commitment to lend. Offers only per Minn. Stat. 47.206 sub 3&4. Loans subject to approval, terms subject to change. Member FDIC. nmlsconsumeraccess.org
