I've been helping people buy homes for more than 33 years. In that time I've watched a lot of first-time buyers get the keys and love the place, and I've seen a few hit setbacks they could have avoided. The good news is that most of these mistakes can be prevented with some planning, clear priorities, and someone in your corner who has done this before.
Here are the ones I see most often, and what I tell my own clients to do instead.
1. Shopping by monthly payment alone
Almost everyone starts with "What will my payment be?" That's a fair question, but the number a lot of people have in mind is only part of the cost. Your real housing payment includes principal and interest, property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance if your loan requires it, HOA dues if there are any, and then utilities and upkeep on top of that.
Taxes, insurance, and HOA dues can go up over time, and they often do. Build a budget with some room to absorb those increases, and plan for regular maintenance from the first day.
2. Touring homes before getting pre-approved
I understand the urge. Looking at homes is the fun part. But if you fall in love with a house before you know what you qualify for, you're setting yourself up for heartbreak.
A written pre-approval tells you your real price range. It also shows sellers you're serious, and it cuts down on surprises later in underwriting. Talk to a lender early, let them review your income, credit, and assets, and get the pre-approval in writing before you start shopping in earnest.
3. Changing your finances in the middle of the loan
This is the one I warn every client about. Buying a car, opening a new credit card, switching jobs, or moving large sums of money around while you're under contract can cause real trouble in underwriting. Even changes that look positive, like a new job with better pay, can create problems.
Lenders usually check your credit, employment, and funds again right before closing. Until you have the keys, keep things steady. Don't take on new debt, and call your lender before you make any financial move.
4. Underestimating the cash you'll need at closing
A lot of buyers save carefully for the down payment and then get caught off guard by closing costs and prepaid items, such as the first year of homeowners insurance and the money that goes into your property tax escrow. Depending on your loan and how the deal is negotiated, the total can be more than you expected.
Coming up short can delay your closing or force last-minute changes to your loan. Ask your lender for a loan estimate early, and ask for a conservative figure for the total cash you'll need, not the best-case number.
5. Overlooking credit and debt-to-income
Many people assume the down payment is what matters most to a lender. It matters, but your credit history and monthly debts matter just as much. A car payment, student loans, and credit card minimums all reduce how much house you can buy.
Stronger credit and manageable debt can open up better loan options and terms. Check your credit well before you start, dispute any errors, and avoid taking on more debt before and during the process.
6. Falling for the house and forgetting the neighborhood
You can renovate a kitchen. You can't move a house. It's easy to focus on the countertops and miss things like the commute, traffic noise, planned development nearby, flood zones, school boundaries, and how far you'll be from the places you go every week.
Drive by in the morning, in the evening, and on a weekend. Look at local planning information when it's available. Decide what matters most for your life and give that the most weight.
7. Waiving inspections or skimping on due diligence
When the market is competitive, some buyers think about skipping or limiting inspections to make their offer stronger. I understand why, but I rarely think it's worth the risk. A good inspection finds things you'll never see on a showing, including the condition of the roof, how the HVAC is performing, plumbing problems, and safety issues.
Those repairs can be expensive, and some of them can affect your financing or whether you can get insurance. Hire qualified inspectors, read the full report, and let us help you separate routine maintenance from a real defect.
8. Confusing fresh paint with a well-kept house
New paint, new flooring, and nice staging can make a home feel move-in ready. They can also draw your eye away from a 20-year-old furnace or a roof near the end of its life. I've seen buyers fall for the finishes and overlook the big components.
The roof, foundation, plumbing, electrical, and HVAC are where the money is. Ask how old the major systems are, ask for permits and receipts when they make sense, and build replacement timelines into your plan.
9. Not reading the HOA fine print
If the home is in an HOA, don't assume the dues cover more than they do. Read the rules too, because they can limit parking, rentals, pets, and exterior changes. Look at the association's finances, since an underfunded HOA can mean a special assessment down the road.
Review the HOA documents, budget, and rules during your due diligence period, and confirm exactly what your dues cover.
10. Having no plan for the appraisal
The lender orders an appraisal to confirm the home is worth what you're borrowing against it. If it comes in below the purchase price, you may need to renegotiate, bring more cash, or change your loan, depending on the situation and the terms of your contract.
A low appraisal can put your closing date at risk. Before you write the offer, we should talk about appraisal strategy so you already know your options if the number comes in short.
11. Leaving insurance until the last minute
Homeowners insurance costs vary a lot by location and by property. Some areas require flood insurance. Some homes are harder or more expensive to insure because of roof age, past claims, or local risk.
Insurance affects your monthly payment, and if you can't get coverage you may not be able to close. Get quotes early, ideally while you're still in due diligence, and confirm any special requirements.
12. Treating the final walk-through as a formality
By closing week, everyone is tired and ready to be done. Still, the final walk-through is your last chance to confirm the home is in the condition your contract calls for, that agreed repairs were completed, and that nothing has changed since you last saw it.
Problems are much harder to fix once you've closed. We'll walk through together, test the appliances and systems that are included, and review repair receipts if the seller provided them.
13. Forgetting what it costs to own a home
Your mortgage payment is only the start. Homes need maintenance and repairs, landscaping, pest control, and eventually a new water heater, furnace, or roof. A house can fit your monthly payment and still strain your budget if you haven't planned for upkeep.
Set aside a maintenance reserve each month, and handle essential repairs before cosmetic upgrades. The new backsplash can wait.
14. Letting emotions override the contract
Buying your first home is exciting, and that excitement can push you to move fast or skim past terms that matter. The contract controls your deadlines, your contingencies, your disclosures, and what happens if something goes wrong.
Here in Utah, missing a contract deadline can cost you real leverage and sometimes your earnest money. Go through the key terms with me, and keep asking questions until you know every date and every responsibility. No question is too basic.
My Final Thoughts
Most first-time buyer mistakes come from three things: incomplete planning, rushed due diligence, or surprises during financing and inspections. All three can be avoided. Put together a strong team, keep your finances steady, and get a clear picture of your total costs early.
If you're thinking about buying your first home, I'd be glad to sit down with you and walk through it before you ever tour a house. That's what I'm here for. You can reach me through my website at agencyutah.com.
Brent Andersen
Principal Broker, The Agency Org.
agencyutah.com
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!