# Best Realtor in Treasure Island, FL: How to Choose the Right Agent

By Brian Baker (@brianbaker) · Published 2026-11-16

Canonical: https://voce.com/@brianbaker/treasure-best-realtor-island-choose-right-agent-4v4i7k

---

Treasure Island is a small barrier island with a big difference from the rest of Tampa Bay: almost everything here is shaped by the water. Flood zones, insurance, seawalls, docks, short-term rental rules, and what "waterfront" actually means on a given street — those are not footnotes here, they are the deal. So when people search "best Realtor in Treasure Island," the real question is: who knows this island well enough to keep you from an expensive surprise? I am Brian Baker, REALTOR® with Keller Williams St. Pete Realty, and I list and sell waterfront on Treasure Island — including my lot at 840 123rd Avenue, with 240 feet of Intracoastal frontage. Here is how to choose the right agent on this island.

## Treasure Island Is Not One Kind of Waterfront

The first thing to know is that "waterfront" on Treasure Island means several different things, and they price and insure very differently.

**Gulf-front.** Homes and condos on the Gulf side — direct beach access, the highest exposure to storm surge, and the most demanding insurance and flood picture. The view is the point, and so is the cost of protecting it.

**Bay-side and Intracoastal.** Isle of Capri, Paradise Island, and Isle of Palms sit on the bay side, with Intracoastal frontage, docks, and boat access. My lot at 840 123rd Avenue is on this side — 240 feet of Intracoastal frontage — and the questions there are about the seawall, the dock, water depth, and bridge clearance, not just the house.

**Inland island homes.** A few blocks off the water, the flood and insurance picture changes again — and so does the price. An agent who quotes you a Gulf-front number for an inland home, or the reverse, has not done the homework.

**Condos.** Much of the island is condos, and each building has its own rules — HOA budget, reserves, pending special assessments, rental restrictions, and whether the building allows short-term rentals at all. The building matters as much as the unit.

Ask any agent which side of the island they have worked on. If they treat all of it as one market, that is your answer.

## What to Look For When You Are Buying

**Someone who checks the flood and insurance picture first.** On a barrier island, this comes before the offer, not after. What flood zone is the property in? What will flood insurance actually cost? What does the homeowner's policy look like on this roof, at this age, on this island? I get quotes early, before you are under contract, so the premium does not surprise you.

**Someone who checks the water side, not just the house.** Seawall condition, dock condition, water depth at the dock, and bridge clearance if you are buying for a boat. A seawall problem is a real line item, and it should be priced into your decision before closing.

**Someone who reads the condo documents.** If you are buying a condo, the HOA budget, reserves, special assessments, and rental rules are part of the purchase — not paperwork to skim at closing. A special assessment in a beach building can be the difference between a deal that works and one that does not.

**Someone who knows the rental rules by building.** Short-term rental rules vary by building and by parcel on Treasure Island. If you are buying with rental income in mind, confirm the rules for that specific building before you offer — not after.

## What to Look For When You Are Selling

**Pricing on the right comps.** Gulf-front, bay-side, and inland homes on Treasure Island do not price the same, and neither do the different island neighborhoods. I price on comparable sales on your side of the island, not on a beach-town median.

**Presentation that reaches waterfront buyers.** A waterfront listing needs professional photos, cinematic video, and marketing that reaches the buyers who can actually buy at that price — including out-of-area buyers who do not drive past the sign. That is how my $2,999,995 lot at 840 123rd Avenue, with its 240 feet of Intracoastal frontage, is presented.

**Honest advice about the water side.** If the seawall, the dock, or the price needs attention before listing, I will tell you. On this island, the water side is half the listing.

## Five Questions to Ask Any Treasure Island Agent

-   **Which side of the island have you worked on — Gulf-front, bay-side, or inland?** And in which neighborhoods?
    
-   **What is the flood zone and insurance picture on a home like mine?** If they cannot walk through it, they have not done the homework.
    
-   **What is the condition of the seawall and dock, and what does that mean for price?** On Treasure Island, this question is not optional.
    
-   **If it is a condo, what is in the HOA budget and reserves — and what are the rental rules?** Get the building, not just the unit.
    
-   **What do your past clients say?** I hold a 5.0-star rating across 12 Google reviews from real clients. Read them — and read any agent's reviews before you hire them.
    

## What I Do on Your File

I work the Gulf Beaches every week, and Treasure Island is where I list and sell waterfront — including the 840 123rd Avenue lot, 240 feet of Intracoastal frontage, MLS TB8559069. When you buy with me, I check the flood and insurance picture, the seawall and dock, and the building rules before you offer. When you sell with me, I price on your side of the island and present the home the way a waterfront buyer expects. Either way, you get me — and I pick up the phone.

## The Bottom Line

The best Realtor in Treasure Island is the one who knows the island's water — Gulf-front versus bay-side versus inland, seawalls and docks, flood and insurance, and the rules of each building. Judge any agent on that local knowledge, honest pricing, and real reviews. If you want someone who works this island and will tell you the truth about your home, let's talk.

Call or text: 727-605-4433

_This article is educational information only, not financial, legal, or tax advice. Real estate markets, prices, insurance, flood zones, and rental rules change. Confirm current details with your lender, insurer, and closing agent before you buy or sell._

Disclaimer: Figures in this article are estimates only, not financial, legal, or tax advice. Rates, prices, and program rules change — verify with a licensed lender, CPA, or attorney before acting. Brian Baker is a licensed real estate agent (FL License #SL3608413), not a lender or financial advisor.

Let's find your next home — click here: [https://www.brianwillsellyourhome.com](https://www.brianwillsellyourhome.com)

Brian Baker, REALTOR®, Keller Williams St. Pete Realty | Arrivato Homes Group, 727-605-4433, brianwillsellyourhome@gmail.com, https://www.brianwillsellyourhome.com
