# Stay, Renovate, Move or Rent Out Your Nashville Home?

By David Hines (@davidhines) · Published 2026-10-26

Canonical: https://voce.com/@davidhines/stay-renovate-move-rent-out-nashville-home-xk8221

---

# **Five questions about home equity, daily life, and choosing a practical next step.**

By David Hines | Keller Williams Nashville-Franklin | Framing Nashville on Substack

A home can gain value while continuing to serve its owners well. Another can appreciate just as much while becoming less suited to the way someone lives. Equity creates possibilities, but the decision starts with what you want to accomplish.

These five questions draw on real situations I’ve encountered around Greater Nashville. They happened at different times, and each household had its own priorities.

1\. **If my home has appreciated, should I sell or stay?**

Appreciation gives you a reason to examine your options. Whether to sell depends on what the move would improve and what you would give up.

A couple I helped buy in Hermitage worked through a difficult search to balance their budget, commute, and other needs. Improvements and landscaping have helped them make that home a long-term fit.

Another couple originally wanted East Nashville but chose Madison rather than accept purchase terms. that made them uncomfortable. They built a life and community there. Earlier conversations about moving gradually fell away.

Both have reasons to stay that extend beyond the value of the property. Begin by identifying what already works and what, if anything, needs to change.

2\. **How do I decide whether to renovate or move?**

Identify the problem, then compare what a renovation could accomplish with what a move would change.

Include costs, disruption, and the parts of your routine you would preserve.

A Smyrna homeowner considered using his equity to move closer to his downtown job. Working from home most of the week then became a tangible option. We had already discussed finishing his basement for recreation, entertaining, and family space; he later confirmed he completed it.

Staying allowed him to improve the house without changing his children’s school situation. A different family might reasonably decide the expense and disruption of a project aren’t worthwhile. The comparison needs realistic project costs and a clear account of what the work would solve.

3\. **When can moving make sense, even if the next home is only slightly larger?**

A modest increase in size can matter when the layout, storage, or location better serves your life.

Compare how you would use the space, alongside the full financial requirements of moving.

A former client moved from the Spring Hill area to the Gallatin area. Her new home was only slightlylarger, but it had significantly more kitchen storage for someone who loves to cook. It also suited her preference for fewer stairs and accommodated heirloom furniture her previous home couldn’t comfortably hold.

Equity carried forward from an earlier purchase, a low mortgage balance, and appreciation in Spring Hill helped her buy with essentially no mortgage. That was her financial situation. For another family, replacing a low-rate mortgage could the same situation difficult to justify. They would need the actual sale proceeds and costs of the next home to compare the choices.

4\. **Could keeping my Nashville property as a rental be an alternative to selling?**

It could, depending on the rental income, expenses, financing, and responsibilities involved - and how retaining the property would affect your next purchase.

A couple who bought their first home near Charlotte Park/Sylvan Park later relocated to the West Coast.

Multiple developers expressed interest in the Nashville property, but they kept it as a rental.

Another couple bought an East Nashville rental nearly 12 years ago. Appreciation on their street led me to raise the possibility of selling. They preferred to continue receiving the substantial monthly rental income.

Rental income alone doesn’t establish whether keeping a property makes sense. Account for repairs, vacancy, operating/management costs, and the other tasks related to ownership. Financing requirements and rental restrictions also need review, with appropriate professional input--lawyers, accountants, tax advisors, etc..

5\. **Where should I begin if I haven’t decided which option fits?**

Start with what you need your home to make possible and what you want to preserve about your current life. You don’t need to choose a path before beginning the discussion.

The Next-Move Guide at `Framing Nashville` gives me a starting point. I personally review your answers and email you a short Next-Move Read with questions worth exploring and a suggested next step.

No call is required.

The initial read begins the conversation. A recommendation about your situation requires a fuller discussion of your property, comparable sales, priorities, and financial considerations.

If you want help taking the next step, we can arrange a meeting to work through those details.

If you’d rather begin directly, email [davidhines@kw.com](mailto:davidhines@kw.com) or call 615-593-8382.

David Hines | Keller Williams Nashville-Franklin