# FHA vs. Conventional Loans: 10 Differences That Decide Your Payment

By Hassan Habib (@hassanhabib) · Published 2026-11-17

Canonical: https://voce.com/@hassanhabib/fha-conventional-loans-differences-decide-payment-xsqzqg

---

The cheaper loan is the one you can actually get approved for — and the more expensive one is often the loan you keep paying for a decade longer. That is the real FHA-versus-conventional decision, and it comes down to how each program prices risk.

FHA insures the lender's loss, so it accepts a credit score as low as **500 with 10% down** and requires mortgage insurance premiums for the entire loan term when you put less than 10% down ([Rize Mortgage](https://rizemtg.com/blog/fha-loan-requirements)). Conventional loans carry no government guarantee, so lenders demand stronger credit but let you **cancel private mortgage insurance** once your balance hits 78% of the original value ([Consumer Financial Protection Bureau](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/when-can-i-remove-private-mortgage-insurance-pmi-from-my-loan-en-202)).

Here are the ten differences that actually move your monthly payment and your long-term cost:

1.  **Credit score floors** — 500 with 10% down for FHA versus 620 as the working conventional floor
    
2.  **Minimum down payment** — 3.5% for FHA versus 3% on eligible conventional programs
    
3.  **Debt-to-income flexibility** — how much of your income each program lets you commit
    
4.  **Mortgage insurance structure** — upfront MIP plus annual MIP versus private monthly PMI
    
5.  **How long the insurance lasts** — life of the loan versus cancellable at 78%
    
6.  **Appraisal and property standards** — HUD Minimum Property Requirements versus a condition-focused conventional appraisal
    
7.  **Loan limits** — county-level FHA ceilings versus conforming limits
    
8.  **Refinance paths** — the FHA streamline versus conventional rate-and-term options
    
9.  **Cash reserves and compensating factors** — what underwriters want to see when the file is tight
    
10.  **Ten-year total cost** — the break-even that decides the whole question
     

## Methodology: how these ten were chosen

I weighed the factors that change an approval decision or a dollar figure, not the ones that only change paperwork. Each item below reflects how a file actually gets underwritten at a retail lender, and every number is tied to published program rules or a current lender guideline.

A candidate only made the list if getting it wrong costs a borrower real money or an avoidable denial. Marketing differences — brand of lender, speed of closing, digital tools — were disqualified, because the same loan can be shopped across lenders regardless of program.

#### Key Takeaways

-   FHA allows a 500 credit score with 10% down; 580 unlocks the 3.5% minimum, while conventional lenders typically work from a 620 floor.
-   FHA charges 1.75% upfront MIP plus roughly 0.55% annual MIP — and with less than 10% down, that annual premium stays for the life of the loan.
-   Conventional PMI can be canceled at 80% loan-to-value on request and must terminate automatically at 78%, so strong borrowers stop paying insurance years earlier.
-   FHA appraisals enforce HUD Minimum Property Requirements, which can force seller repairs a conventional appraisal would ignore.
-   The break-even is usually equity, not rate: if you can reach 20% equity quickly, conventional wins the long game.

## 1\. Credit score floors set the entry point

FHA is the lowest-credit-score mortgage in the mainstream market: a **500 score qualifies with 10% down**, and 580 unlocks the 3.5% down payment ([Rize Mortgage](https://rizemtg.com/blog/fha-loan-requirements)). Conventional lenders typically work from a 620 minimum, and pricing improves sharply above 740.

**Best for:** buyers rebuilding credit after a setback, a thin credit file, or a recent gap in reporting.

The catch is lender overlays. FHA sets the floor, but individual lenders routinely require 600 or 620 even on FHA files, so a 560 score is a shopping problem as much as an underwriting one ([Rize Mortgage](https://rizemtg.com/blog/fha-loan-requirements)). Ask each lender for its own overlay before you pay for an appraisal.

## 2\. Down payment minimums differ by half a point

FHA requires 3.5% down at a 580 score or better and 10% down for scores between 500 and 579 ([Rize Mortgage](https://rizemtg.com/blog/fha-loan-requirements)). Eligible conventional programs reach as low as **3% down** for qualifying borrowers, which narrows a gap most buyers assume is much wider ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)).

**Best for:** FHA when savings are the binding constraint and credit is under 620; conventional when the down payment is already close to 5% or more.

Two attributes decide this one: the cash gap itself, and who will accept the money. On a $350,000 purchase, 3.5% down is $12,250 and 3% down is $10,500 — a **$1,750 difference** that rarely decides anything on its own ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)). FHA also accepts eligible gift funds and down payment assistance toward the required investment, subject to source-of-funds documentation, which matters more than the half-point for many first-time buyers ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)).

## 3\. Debt-to-income flexibility decides borderline files

FHA generally looks for total debt at or below **43% of gross monthly income**, with a housing ratio near 31%, but allows approvals up to 50% or higher when compensating factors are documented ([Rize Mortgage](https://rizemtg.com/blog/fha-loan-requirements)). Conventional guidance is often cited at a 45% ceiling, though automated underwriting can approve beyond it ([Freedom Mortgage](https://www.freedommortgage.com/learn/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional-loans)).

**Best for:** FHA when a car payment or student loan pushes you over the conventional line; conventional when your ratios are already comfortable.

This is where files are actually lost. A borrower at 47% DTI with strong reserves and stable income is a reasonable FHA approval and a difficult conventional one — and paying off a single revolving balance can flip the answer the other way.

## 4\. Mortgage insurance is structured differently

FHA charges two premiums: an upfront premium of **1.75% of the base loan amount**, which most borrowers finance into the mortgage, plus an annual premium typically collected monthly ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)). Conventional loans charge no upfront premium and no FHA premium at all — private mortgage insurance applies only below 20% down, priced by credit and loan-to-value.

**Best for:** conventional when your credit is strong enough to earn cheap PMI pricing; FHA when the upfront cost can be financed and monthly cash flow is the constraint.

The CFPB's plain-language framing is that PMI rates vary by down payment and credit score but are generally cheaper than FHA rates for borrowers with good credit, while FHA insurance costs the same no matter your credit score ([Consumer Financial Protection Bureau](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/what-is-mortgage-insurance-and-how-does-it-work-en-1953)). That single sentence explains why a 760-score buyer rarely belongs in FHA.

![FHA MIP versus conventional PMI cost chart](https://convex.voce.com/api/storage/00758066-f418-4b52-83bc-f45a1606cf92)

## 5\. Insurance duration is the biggest long-term cost

With less than 10% down, FHA's annual premium generally stays for the **full loan term**; with 10% or more down, it ends after 11 years ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)). Conventional PMI terminates automatically once your balance is scheduled to reach **78% of the original value**, and you can request cancellation at 80% ([Consumer Financial Protection Bureau](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/when-can-i-remove-private-mortgage-insurance-pmi-from-my-loan-en-202)).

**Best for:** conventional for anyone who expects to reach 20% equity within several years — through payments, appreciation, or both.

On a $337,750 FHA loan with 3.5% down, the standard 0.55% annual premium runs about **$155 per month** at the start, roughly $1,858 a year, and it does not stop at 78% loan-to-value ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)). Cancellation also isn't automatic on request: the CFPB notes your servicer must grant it only if you ask in writing, are current, have no junior liens, and can show the home hasn't declined below its original value ([Consumer Financial Protection Bureau](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/when-can-i-remove-private-mortgage-insurance-pmi-from-my-loan-en-202)).

## 6\. FHA appraisals enforce property condition standards

An FHA appraisal is a condition review as much as a valuation. HUD's Minimum Property Requirements cover structural soundness, safe and functional utilities, and health or safety hazards, and the appraiser can require repairs that the seller must complete before closing ([Rize Mortgage](https://rizemtg.com/blog/fha-loan-requirements)).

**Best for:** conventional on a fixer-upper, a property with peeling paint or an older roof, or a competitive market where sellers will not take a repair demand.

The mechanics matter here. HUD's own field guidance distinguishes repairs the appraiser requires to meet those minimum standards and permits the borrower to pay for them, with the cost potentially added to the sales price before the maximum mortgage is calculated ([HUD](https://entp.hud.gov/sfohlp/f17alrfdhlp.cfm)). In a hot market, that repair list is a real negotiating disadvantage — some sellers simply reject FHA offers.

![FHA appraisal property condition requirements](https://convex.voce.com/api/storage/36d5c6ab-8877-4f92-b852-0c10e281f218)

## 7\. Loan limits cap what each program can finance

FHA sets county-by-county loan limits that run below conforming limits in most of the country, while conforming loans follow the Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac limits and jumbo conventional loans can exceed them ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)).

**Best for:** FHA in lower-price markets where its ceiling is not binding; conventional — including jumbo — for higher-price homes.

Two attributes decide this one: the county ceiling and the hard stop. FHA publishes limits county by county, so the same loan amount can be insurable in one market and ineligible a county away; conforming limits follow Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and jumbo conventional loans can exceed them entirely ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)). Because an FHA loan above its limit simply cannot be insured, the limit functions as a disqualifier rather than a pricing adjustment — check the figure for your county before you fall in love with a house.

## 8\. Refinance paths point in different directions

FHA loans carry a streamline refinance option that allows a rate reduction with reduced documentation, while conventional loans refinance through standard rate-and-term or cash-out programs with full underwriting ([Freedom Mortgage](https://www.freedommortgage.com/learn/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional-loans)).

**Best for:** FHA borrowers who may need to refinance quickly or with a thinner file; conventional borrowers who plan to use equity later.

The strategic play most FHA borrowers miss is refinancing _out_ of FHA entirely. Because conventional PMI can be canceled on request once the balance reaches 80% of the original value and must terminate automatically at 78%, a conventional refinance removes the annual premium permanently once you reach roughly that equity level ([Consumer Financial Protection Bureau](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/when-can-i-remove-private-mortgage-insurance-pmi-from-my-loan-en-202)) — and that single move is usually worth more than any rate difference between the two programs at origination. The trade-off is that a conventional refinance brings full underwriting and a new appraisal, so the file has to qualify again at the new loan-to-value.

## 9\. Reserves and compensating factors carry more weight than borrowers expect

Neither program publishes a flat reserve requirement, but both let underwriters weigh documented strengths — cash reserves, long employment history, minimal payment shock — against a weakness in the file. FHA states this explicitly, allowing approvals above the standard 43% ratio when compensating factors are present ([Rize Mortgage](https://rizemtg.com/blog/fha-loan-requirements)).

**Best for:** FHA when you have savings but imperfect credit; conventional when credit is strong and the weakness sits somewhere else.

The concrete difference is the bar for a second look. FHA states explicitly that it will approve above the standard 43% ratio when compensating factors are documented, and those factors are named — cash reserves, strong employment history, minimal payment shock ([Rize Mortgage](https://rizemtg.com/blog/fha-loan-requirements)). A file that fails at one lender often clears at another on the same program, which is why shopping the lender overlay matters more than shopping the rate alone.

## 10\. Ten-year total cost decides it, not the rate quote

Add every cost across a realistic holding period and the ranking usually flips. FHA wins on entry — lower score, lower cash — while conventional wins on duration, because its insurance can be removed ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)).

**Best for:** FHA if you will hold the home a few years, refinance out, or cannot qualify otherwise; conventional if you expect to stay, build equity, or buy in a competitive market.

Run the arithmetic on the loan you would actually take. A $337,750 FHA loan with 3.5% down pays roughly $1,858 a year in annual premium with no scheduled end under the standard schedule ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-vs-conventional)). A conventional borrower at 5% down who reaches 78% loan-to-value in a few years stops paying insurance entirely — and every month after that is money the FHA borrower keeps paying.

## Decision table: FHA vs. conventional at a glance

What decides the outcome

FHA loan

Conventional loan

Credit score you need

500 with 10% down; 580 for 3.5% down, though many lenders overlay higher

No single agency minimum on automated underwriting, but 620 remains the working floor at most lenders

Cash needed at closing

3.5% down plus a 1.75% upfront premium most borrowers finance

As low as 3% on eligible programs, with no upfront insurance premium

What insurance costs monthly

Annual premium of about 0.55% on a 30-year loan above 95% LTV, roughly $155 a month on a $337,750 balance

PMI priced by credit and loan-to-value; cheaper than FHA for strong credit

When insurance stops

Full loan term below 10% down; after 11 years at 10% or more

Automatically at 78% of original value, on request at 80%

Property and appraisal risk

HUD Minimum Property Requirements can require seller repairs before closing

Condition review without HUD's minimum standards, so fewer repair demands

Who it fits best

Lower scores, thin savings, higher debt ratios, first-time buyers

Strong credit, 5% or more down, long holding periods, competitive offers

## Choosing between FHA and conventional: five borrower profiles

Match your situation to the pick, then verify it against a real scenario rather than a rule of thumb.

**If your score is under 620 and you have little saved,** FHA is usually the only door open. Take the 3.5% down at 580 or better, expect a seller who may resist the repair list, and plan to refinance into conventional once you reach roughly 20% equity.

**If your score is 720 or higher with 5% down,** conventional almost always costs less over time. Your PMI is priced to your credit, it cancels at 78% loan-to-value, and you avoid the 1.75% upfront premium entirely.

**If your debt-to-income ratio sits between 45% and 50%,** FHA's documented compensating-factor path is more forgiving. Bring reserves and a stable employment history to the conversation — that is the evidence underwriters weigh.

**If you are buying a home that needs work,** go conventional unless you plan to use FHA's renovation products. A peeling-paint finding on an FHA appraisal can stall a closing that a conventional loan would clear.

**If you are near the FHA county limit,** run the conventional number before you assume you are priced out. Conforming limits sit above FHA limits in most markets, and a jumbo conventional loan may still beat an FHA loan you cannot fully insure.

Two borrowers with identical income can land on opposite answers here, which is why the useful next step is a side-by-side quote on the same property, the same day, with both programs priced out to the month. Ask for the annual insurance cost, the projected date insurance drops off, and the total paid over ten years. Those three numbers decide it — not the rate on the top of the page.
