# The Appraisal Missed the Price. Now What?

By Jennifer Chicano (@jenniferchicano) · Published 2026-11-20

Canonical: https://voce.com/@jenniferchicano/low-appraisal-below-contract-price-mortgage-sq2wty

---

You’re under contract for:

**$500,000.**

The appraisal comes back at:

**$475,000.**

That is a **$25,000 gap.**

Now what?

First: do not assume the deal is dead.

A low appraisal creates a problem to solve. It does not automatically create a failed closing.

## Why the Appraisal Matters

For a conventional purchase, Fannie Mae generally calculates the loan-to-value ratio using the [**lower of the sales price or the appraised value**.](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b2-1.2-01/loan-value-ltv-ratios)

That means the lender is not simply financing a percentage of whatever you agreed to pay.

The appraisal helps establish the value being used for the loan.

So if the contract price is $500,000 but the appraisal is $475,000, the financing may now be based on that lower number.

## The Down Payment Can Change

Here is where buyers usually feel it.

Suppose you planned to put 10% down on a $500,000 purchase.

Your original structure may have looked like:

**Purchase price:** $500,000  
**Loan amount:** $450,000  
**Down payment:** $50,000

Then the appraisal comes in at $475,000.

That same $450,000 loan is now roughly **94.7% of the appraised value**.

The financing structure you started with may no longer work the same way.

You may need to:

-   reduce the loan amount
    
-   bring additional cash
    
-   restructure the financing
    
-   renegotiate the purchase price
    

That is why a low appraisal can affect more than the seller.

It can affect your mortgage.

## Option 1: Renegotiate the Price

The cleanest solution is often for the buyer and seller to agree on a lower purchase price.

If the seller agrees to reduce the price closer to the appraised value, the financing may fall back into place.

Whether the seller has to renegotiate depends on the contract and any appraisal protections that were negotiated.

That part is a conversation for your real estate agent and, when appropriate, your attorney.

## Option 2: Split the Difference

Sometimes the seller will not reduce the price all the way.

The parties may agree to meet somewhere in the middle.

For example:

**Contract price:** $500,000  
**Appraised value:** $475,000  
**New price:** $487,500

Now the seller accepts less and the buyer covers part of the difference.

But before agreeing to that, the lender needs to recalculate the loan.

Do not assume the extra money is simply added to your original down payment.

## Option 3: Bring More Cash

A buyer may decide the property is still worth the contract price and bring additional cash to cover the gap.

That can work.

But the lender still bases the mortgage calculation on the applicable property value.

The extra cash does not magically make the appraisal higher.

It simply means the buyer is choosing to pay more than the appraised value.

And before doing that, ask yourself:

**Do I still have enough cash for closing costs, reserves and life after closing?**

Do not drain the account just to save a deal.

## Option 4: Challenge the Appraisal

If there is a legitimate issue with the appraisal, there may be a process to request a **reconsideration of value**.

That is not the same thing as saying:

**“We don’t like the number.”**

A reconsideration request should identify something specific, such as:

-   incorrect property information
    
-   unsupported adjustments
    
-   relevant comparable sales that were missed
    
-   inaccurate data
    
-   another material issue affecting the value conclusion
    

For eligible Fannie Mae loans, the lender must have a process for a [**borrower-initiated reconsideration of value**.](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-12/appraisal-quality-matters)

The request has to be supported.

The goal is not to pressure the appraiser into hitting the contract price.

The goal is to correct or reconsider an appraisal if the original value is not adequately supported.

## A Second Appraisal Is Not Automatic

This is another common misconception.

You generally cannot keep ordering appraisals until somebody gives you the number you want.

If the lender has concerns about the reliability of the appraisal, there are specific review procedures.

That can include asking the original appraiser to address deficiencies, obtaining an appraisal review, or in certain circumstances obtaining a new appraisal.

The lender still has to rely on the [**most reliable appraisal**](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-12/appraisal-quality-matters), not simply the highest one.

## The Contract Price Does Not Prove Value

A buyer and seller can agree to any price they want.

That does not automatically establish market value for mortgage purposes.

The appraiser analyzes market data, including [comparable properties](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-07/sales-comparison-approach-section-appraisal-report), to develop an opinion of value.

That is why multiple offers do not necessarily guarantee the property will appraise at the winning bid.

The market may support it.

Or it may not.

## What I Want Buyers to Do

If an [appraisal comes in low,](https://voce.com/@jenniferchicano/appraisal-complete-not-clear-to-close-hwgxe6) do not immediately panic or start offering more cash.

First, we run the numbers.

I want to know:

**How does the lower value affect the loan?**

Then the buyer and agent can evaluate the contract side.

Those are two separate conversations that need to happen together.

## The Better Question

Do not ask:

**“Did the appraisal kill the deal?”**

Ask:

**“What changed, and what are our options?”**

Sometimes the answer is a price reduction.

Sometimes it is additional cash.

Sometimes the financing gets restructured.

Sometimes the appraisal deserves another look.

The important thing is knowing the numbers before making the next move.

## About Jennifer Chicano

Jennifer Chicano, CMA™, is Your Loan Chic — a Certified Mortgage Advisor™ and mortgage broker helping buyers understand how appraisal results affect financing before they make decisions about the contract. NMLS #1194079 | Zero Point Mortgage Services NMLS #1216108.

[**Schedule a Mortgage Strategy Call**](https://my.yourloanchic.com/widget/booking/Cn0QpUI0ncKFY5lHM9ui)

_Information is for educational purposes only and is not a commitment to lend, legal advice, tax advice or financial advice. Appraisal, financing and contract requirements vary by borrower, property, lender, loan program and transaction. Buyers should consult their real estate agent and appropriate legal professionals regarding contractual rights and obligations. All loans are subject to underwriting and credit approval._
