# Permanent vs. Temporary Rate Buydowns: Which Saves You More?

By Michelle Griffith (@michellegriffith2) · Published 2026-11-16

Canonical: https://voce.com/@michellegriffith2/permanent-temporary-rate-buydowns-saves-prkx60

---

If a seller or builder is paying, take the temporary buydown. If you are paying with your own money and plan to keep the loan past roughly five years, buy permanent points. That is the whole decision in two sentences, and it comes down to who funds the concession and how long you hold the mortgage.

The two options also pull from different wallets. A temporary buydown is almost always funded by the seller or builder as a concession, so its relief arrives in years one and two and then stops. Permanent points come out of your own cash and keep paying you back for as long as you hold the loan. The worked example below shows exactly where those two curves cross.

Buyer concern

2-1 temporary buydown

3-2-1 temporary buydown

Permanent points

What it actually does

Subsidizes your payment 2 points below the note rate in year one and 1 point below in year two, then stops

Subsidizes 3 points below in year one, 2 in year two, 1 in year three, then stops

Permanently lowers the note rate itself, so every payment for the loan's life is smaller

Who typically funds it

Seller, builder, or lender as a concession; borrowers generally cannot self-fund on conforming loans

Same funding rules as the 2-1, with a larger deposit required

Usually the buyer, though a seller credit can cover points when the program allows

Upfront cost to you

$0 when seller-funded; the money sits in an escrow account rather than your pocket

$0 when seller-funded, but a bigger escrow deposit, so it eats more of the seller's credit cap

1% of the loan amount per point, so $4,000 per point on a $400,000 loan

What happens when it ends

Payment steps up twice, then settles at the full note-rate payment in year three

Payment steps up three times before reaching the note rate in year four

Nothing changes, because the note rate was already reduced

How it affects qualifying

None. Underwriting still qualifies you at the full note rate, so it does not raise your purchase power

None for the same reason

You qualify at the bought-down rate, which can be the difference on a tight debt-to-income ratio

Best for

Buyers expecting income growth, a move, or a refinance within a few years

Buyers who want maximum early relief and have a large concession available

Buyers staying well past break-even who want a permanently smaller payment

Main limitation

The relief is temporary, and the payment jumps whether or not your income did

Highest total cost of the three, and the steepest payment shock in year four

Points are non-refundable if you sell or refinance before break-even

#### Key Takeaways

-   A temporary buydown subsidizes your payment for one to three years without changing your note rate; permanent points lower the rate for the entire loan term.
-   Temporary buydowns are almost always seller- or builder-funded, while discount points are usually paid by the buyer, so the two options are not competing for the same dollars.
-   Two points on a $400,000 loan at 6.5% break even in roughly 62 months; a 2-1 buydown on the same loan returns about $9,104 in its first two years.
-   Seller credit caps run 3% to 9% on conventional loans depending on down payment, 6% on FHA and USDA, and 4% on VA for concessions beyond normal closing costs.
-   No seller credit can fund your down payment, and unused credit generally does not come back to you as cash.

## How do permanent and temporary buydowns differ?

A temporary buydown never changes your interest rate. Money is deposited into an escrow account at closing and used to cover the gap between a reduced payment and your real note-rate payment. A permanent buydown changes the note rate itself, lowering every payment until the loan is paid off.

That distinction drives everything else. Because the note rate stays intact on a temporary buydown, your loan documents still show the full rate, and underwriting qualifies you at the full rate, not the subsidized one ([Lenny](https://www.lendercity.com/blog/understanding-mortgage-interest-rate-buydowns)). The 2-1 buydown therefore eases your monthly budget without increasing what you can afford to borrow. A permanent buydown works the opposite way: the lower rate is generally part of the qualifying payment, which is why some buyers use points to fit a house they could not otherwise finance.

One more structural difference matters for negotiations. On conforming and most government loans, temporary buydowns are funded by an interested party, typically the seller, builder, or lender, as a concession. Borrowers generally cannot fund their own temporary buydown on conforming loans ([Vantage Mortgage Brokers](https://vantagemortgagegroup.com/mortgageratebuydowns)). So the two options rarely compete for the same dollars: one spends the seller's money, the other spends yours.

### The 2-1, the 3-2-1, and permanent points

The 2-1 is the workhorse. Your payment is calculated as if the rate were two percentage points lower in year one and one point lower in year two, then the full note-rate payment begins in year three. On a 6.5% note rate, that means an effective 4.5% in year one, 5.5% in year two, and 6.5% from year three onward.

The 3-2-1 stretches the same idea one year further and three points deeper: 3 points below in year one, 2 in year two, 1 in year three. It produces the largest early relief and the largest escrow deposit, which is exactly why it consumes more of a seller's available credit.

Permanent points are a different instrument. One point costs 1% of the loan amount and, as a rough rule of thumb, buys about a quarter point off the rate, though the actual tradeoff moves daily with pricing, program, and lender ([Vantage Mortgage Brokers](https://vantagemortgagegroup.com/mortgageratebuydowns)). On a $500,000 loan, one point is $5,000 and might move 6.50% to 6.25%.

## Which one saves more in the long run?

Permanent points win on total dollars if you keep the loan long enough to clear break-even, and the temporary buydown wins if you do not. The crossover is not close to 30 years; it is usually somewhere between four and six years.

Run the numbers on the same $400,000, 30-year loan at 6.5%. The 2-1 buydown cuts principal and interest to roughly $2,027 in year one and $2,271 in year two before returning to $2,528 in year three, for about $9,104 in total savings ([Luminate Bank](https://www.luminate.bank/temporary-vs-permanent-mortgage-rate-buydowns)). Buying the rate down to 6.0% with two points costs $8,000 and lowers the payment to about $2,398 for the life of the loan, which saves roughly $130 a month and takes about 62 months to repay its own cost.

Read that pair carefully, because it explains why the answer flips on timeline. The buydown's $9,104 lands entirely in years one and two, then stops forever. The points' $8,000 comes back around month 62, and every month after that is pure savings for up to 24 more years. A buyer who sells or refinances in year three keeps the full buydown benefit and recovers none of the point cost.

There is a second, less obvious long-run effect. Points reduce the rate on the actual note, which lowers the interest you pay over the amortization schedule, not just the payment. A temporary buydown lowers what you pay during the subsidy window without changing how the loan amortizes, so the principal balance at year five is essentially the same either way. Permanent points also lower your rate for refinance comparisons, since a future lender will be pricing against a lower existing payment.

The exception worth knowing: if rates fall and you refinance, points paid on the original loan are gone. Future rate movement is a possibility, not a plan, and an expensive buydown is not automatically worth it because you expect to refinance later ([Lenny](https://www.lendercity.com/blog/understanding-mortgage-interest-rate-buydowns)).

**Mini-verdict:** past roughly five years on the loan, permanent points save more. Inside five years, the temporary buydown saves more, and it does so with someone else's money.

$9,104$9,104[Luminate Bank](https://www.luminate.bank/temporary-vs-permanent-mortgage-rate-buydowns)

## What can seller credits legally pay for?

Seller credits pay eligible closing costs, prepaid items, discount points, and buydown escrow deposits, subject to each loan program's contribution cap. What they cannot do is fund your down payment, reimburse your reserves, or come back to you as cash.

The caps are set by loan program, and they are the single most useful numbers to know before you write an offer.

Loan program

Maximum seller contribution

How the cap is measured

Conventional, primary residence or second home, less than 10% down

3%

Lower of sales price or appraised value

Conventional, 10% to under 25% down

6%

Lower of sales price or appraised value

Conventional, 25% or more down

9%

Lower of sales price or appraised value

Conventional, investment property

2% at every loan-to-value ratio

Lower of sales price or appraised value

FHA

6% of the sales price

Sales price, and the 6% also covers interest rate buydowns and the upfront mortgage insurance premium

VA

4% of reasonable value for concessions beyond normal closing costs

The value on the VA Notice of Value, not the sales price

USDA

6% of the sales price

Sales price, for eligible loan purposes only

Those tiers come from Fannie Mae's interested party contribution rules, with the FHA and USDA caps from HUD and the VA limit from the VA Lender's Handbook ([Zeitro](https://www.zeitro.com/faqs/what-are-the-seller-concession-limits-for-conventional-fha-va-and-usda)).

The VA rule deserves its own paragraph because it is the most misread. Normal seller-paid closing costs and normal discount points sit outside the 4% entirely and carry no VA percentage cap. What counts toward the 4% is everything else of value: a seller-paid VA funding fee, prepaid taxes and insurance, debt payoffs, and the escrow money funding a temporary buydown ([Zeitro](https://www.zeitro.com/faqs/what-are-the-seller-concession-limits-for-conventional-fha-va-and-usda)). A seller-funded 2-1 buydown on a $500,000 VA purchase costs roughly $11,388 to fund, which fits inside the $20,000 cap but leaves less room for a funding fee or debt payoff ([JD.Mortgage](https://jd.mortgage/va-seller-concessions)).

On FHA, the 6% ceiling covers origination fees, closing costs, prepaid items, discount points, temporary and permanent buydowns, and the upfront mortgage insurance premium, but never the 3.5% minimum down payment ([Lower Mortgage](https://www.lower.com/mortgages/fha-loan/fha-seller-concession-limits)). Exceed the cap and the excess is treated as an inducement to purchase, which can force the transaction to be restructured before closing.

A practical constraint sits underneath all of this: the credit can never exceed your actual eligible costs. A 9% allowance on a 25%-down conventional loan is meaningless if your closing costs only reach 4% of the price. Ask for the dollar figure your costs support, not the theoretical percentage.

## How does Citywide handle buydowns and seller credits?

Citywide Home Mortgage, a division of Guaranteed Rate operating as Citywide Home Mortgage with NMLS #2611, structures buydowns through its loan officer network, and the program rules that govern your file are the investor and agency guidelines above plus any lender overlays that apply to your scenario. Because those overlays and daily pricing shift, the specific structure for your purchase gets priced and documented by your loan officer rather than published as a single rate sheet.

What that means in practice: the 2-1 and 3-2-1 buydowns on a Citywide conventional or government loan follow Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, FHA, VA, or USDA rules depending on which program you use. The seller credit that funds the buydown counts against that program's cap. Your loan documents will show the full note rate even when a buydown is subsidizing your payment, and underwriting will qualify you at that full rate.

Citywide's loan options span conventional, FHA, VA, jumbo, adjustable-rate, and renovation financing, so the buydown conversation usually starts with which program fits the property and your down payment, then moves to whether a concession should be spent on a temporary buydown, permanent points, or a lower purchase price.

When you compare those three uses, run them side by side rather than assuming. On a $500,000 loan, a $12,000 price reduction lowers the payment by roughly $60 to $75 a month, while the same $12,000 applied to a buydown moves the payment far more in the short term ([Vantage Mortgage Brokers](https://vantagemortgagegroup.com/mortgageratebuydowns)). The price cut lowers your loan balance and property taxes permanently, so the right answer still depends on your timeline.

## What does each buydown genuinely do worse?

A comparison without tradeoffs is an advertisement, so here is what each option actually costs you.

The temporary buydown's weakness is timing. Its relief expires on a schedule that has nothing to do with your life. The payment rises in year two and again in year three whether or not the raise arrived, and you qualified at the full note rate the entire time, so the buydown never bought you a larger house. If you funded it yourself on a program that allows it, you spent real money for savings that vanish.

Permanent points have a different failure mode: they are irreversible. Sell, refinance, or pay the loan off before break-even and the money is simply spent, with no refund ([Vantage Mortgage Brokers](https://vantagemortgagegroup.com/mortgageratebuydowns)). Pricing also varies day to day, and some days a full point buys very little rate reduction. Paying 1% of the loan amount for a rate improvement that trims only a few dollars a month is a bad trade regardless of how long you stay.

Both options share one weakness: neither beats a larger down payment or a stronger reserve account if those dollars are genuinely needed elsewhere. A buydown that empties your savings converts a payment problem into a repair-and-vacancy problem.

**Mini-verdict:** neither option fails on price. The temporary buydown fails on timing and permanent points fail on permanence, so pick the failure you can actually live with given your holding period.

## Choose the temporary buydown if…

-   A seller or builder is offering a concession and you want the largest possible reduction in monthly outlay during the first two to three years.
    
-   You expect your income to rise, or you plan to move or refinance inside the buydown window, so the payment step-ups will not strain you.
    
-   You want breathing room for furnishing, moving, and early repairs without spending your own cash.
    

**Mini-verdict:** the temporary buydown wins for any buyer whose horizon is shorter than the break-even window or who is spending a seller's money rather than their own.

## Choose permanent points if…

-   You are paying with your own money and expect to keep this loan well past five years.
    
-   You need the lower payment to qualify, since points reduce the rate underwriting uses and a temporary buydown does not.
    
-   You want a permanently smaller payment and the certainty of not depending on a future refinance.
    

**Mini-verdict:** permanent points win for the buyer who is certain of the long hold, because no other structure delivers a smaller payment for every remaining month of the loan.

## Work with Michelle Griffith in Carson City

Michelle Griffith is a loan officer with Citywide Home Mortgage in Carson City, Nevada, NMLS #2736336, serving buyers across Northern Nevada. She runs the buydown math against your actual timeline, your loan program, and the seller credit your contract can support, so the decision rests on your numbers rather than a general rule.

If you are weighing a seller concession between a temporary buydown, permanent points, and a price reduction, bring your purchase contract and your loan estimate. Michelle will model all three side by side before you sign.

Reach Michelle Griffith at Citywide Home Mortgage, Carson City, Nevada, NMLS #2736336.

?Frequently Asked Questions4 questions

1Do I have to refinance when a temporary buydown ends?

No. A temporary buydown expires on its own schedule and never requires a refinance. Your original note rate stays in place the entire time; the escrow account simply runs out after the buydown period. If you refinance or pay the loan off early, any unused buydown funds are typically credited back and applied to your payoff, which is a meaningful advantage over discount points that carry no refund at all.

2How much can a seller actually contribute on my loan?

Conventional loans generally allow 3% of the price with less than 10% down, 6% from 10% to under 25% down, and 9% at 25% or more down, measured against the lower of the sales price or appraised value. Investment properties cap at 2% at every loan-to-value ratio. FHA and USDA allow 6%, and VA caps concessions beyond normal closing costs at 4% of reasonable value.

3Can seller credits cover my down payment?

No. Seller credits cannot fund the down payment, satisfy reserve requirements, or be handed to you as cash on conventional and FHA loans. The credit is limited to eligible closing costs and prepaid items, and it can never exceed what those costs actually total. If the agreed credit is larger than your eligible costs, the transaction usually gets restructured before closing.

4Can I combine a seller-funded buydown with buying my own points?

They are not really competing options because they draw on different money. A permanent buydown paid with your own cash is a long-term investment that pays back over roughly five years. A seller-funded temporary buydown spends the seller's money and delivers its entire benefit within the first two or three years. Many buyers use the concession for a temporary buydown and keep their own savings intact.

#### Run the buydown math before you sign

Bring your purchase contract and loan estimate and we'll model the temporary buydown, permanent points, and price reduction side by side.

[Talk to Michelle Griffith](/@michellegriffith2)
