# Punaluu Condo Crisis: A Guide for Foreign Investors By Sarah Haas (@sarahhaas) · Published 2026-10-28 Canonical: https://voce.com/@sarahhaas/punaluu-condo-crisis-guide-foreign-investors-tuxwj6 --- Hurricane Lala struck Hawaii Island on Aug. 15, 2026, and more than two months later roughly **100 condominiums in Punaluu remain without drinking water or working sewer** because the private utility that serves them cannot pay for repairs ([Big Island Now](https://bigislandnow.com/2026/10/04/nearly-100-customers-still-without-drinking-water-and-sewer-after-lala-damaged-private-punalu%CA%BBu-utility)). For a foreign investor eyeing a discounted beachfront condo, that failure changes every part of the decision. Punaluu (also spelled Punaluʻu) is a rural stretch of the Kaʻū District on the Big Island's southeastern coast, known for its black sand beach. Its condo communities — Colony I (76 units) and the smaller Kalana Estates — sit in the service area of a privately owned utility, Punaluʻu Water and Sanitation. When the storm's floodwaters buried the potable water well site under mud and debris, the utility's owner said the repair bill — roughly **half a million dollars** — was not in the budget, and as of late October there is still **no projected timeline** for restoring water ([Hawaii Tribune-Herald](https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/2026/10/21/hawaii-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)). #### Key Takeaways - Punaluu's condo communities have been without drinking water and sewer for more than two months since Hurricane Lala, because a privately owned utility can't fund repairs - The utility's owner says the roughly $500,000 repair estimate isn't in the budget and there's no projected timeline for restoring potable water - For investors, the crisis is a case study in infrastructure risk — distressed pricing can look cheap until you price in a utility with no money, no insurance and no timeline - The county's interest in taking over the water system is the main wildcard for long-term condo value ≈100condominiums still without drinking water and sewer after Hurricane Lala[Big Island Now](https://bigislandnow.com/2026/10/04/nearly-100-customers-still-without-drinking-water-and-sewer-after-lala-damaged-private-punalu%CA%BBu-utility) ## Punaluu's water system failed at the private utility The storm did not spare the infrastructure that keeps the condos livable. Hurricane Lala's floodwaters and debris engulfed the potable water well site along Hawaiʻi Belt Road, destroying the well's motor and pump, and flooded the utility's maintenance shed, wastewater plant and lift station ([Big Island Now](https://bigislandnow.com/2026/10/04/nearly-100-customers-still-without-drinking-water-and-sewer-after-lala-damaged-private-punalu%CA%BBu-utility)). A road crew also severed the working wellhead while clearing the highway. Electricity came back weeks ago, but water never did. That utility is Punaluʻu Water and Sanitation, a private company owned by Black Sand Beach, a limited liability corporation whose principal owner and developer is Eva Liu. Liu bought roughly 433 acres near Colony I seven years ago with plans for a resort-style development, and the utility now appears to be in financial trouble — it had already filed with the state Public Utilities Commission (PUC) requesting major rate increases before the storm ([Big Island Now](https://bigislandnow.com/2026/10/04/nearly-100-customers-still-without-drinking-water-and-sewer-after-lala-damaged-private-punalu%CA%BBu-utility)). ![Punaluu water system infrastructure after hurricane damage](https://convex.voce.com/api/storage/5f8c2bfa-165f-4b98-aee0-1ef4cbd30a9f) The scale of the failure is the investor story. At an Oct. 19 hearing in Pahala called by the PUC, the utility's attorney, Colin Sakumoto, said repairs to restore potable water would cost an estimated half a million dollars — "Securing a half million dollars when you're not even providing water to the customers — that's unlikely to happen," he said, adding that there is **no projected timeline** for restoring water ([Hawaii Tribune-Herald](https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/2026/10/21/hawaii-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)). The utility is not insured, has no money secured for repairs, and could not even afford a portable water tank, according to reporting on the same meeting ([Hawaii Tribune-Herald](https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/2026/10/21/hawaii-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)). ## The crisis shifts the risk equation for foreign investors For a prospective buyer, the temptation is obvious: condos in a storm-damaged beachfront community, selling at a discount, with the county reportedly interested in taking over the water system. The reality is more sobering. **The distressed price may be cheap precisely because the asset carries an unresolved utility liability** — and as a non-resident owner, you face financial hurdles mainland buyers do not. Start with the cash-flow reality of the units themselves. Colony I's president, Jeff Silva, bought two 1,500-gallon tanks on his personal credit card after the storm so residents could bathe and wash dishes — the water was not potable, and people turned to gallon jugs for drinking ([Big Island Now](https://bigislandnow.com/2026/10/04/nearly-100-customers-still-without-drinking-water-and-sewer-after-lala-damaged-private-punalu%CA%BBu-utility)). Most units are vacation rentals, which means a condo with no running water and no working toilets is a rental with **zero occupancy income** until service returns. Some owners are already paying out of pocket for portable toilets. The tax picture compounds the risk on exit. If you are a foreign national (not a U.S. citizen or green-card holder), selling triggers **HARPTA, Hawaii's 7.25% state withholding on the gross sales price, plus FIRPTA, the federal 15% withholding for foreign sellers** — roughly 22.25% of the sale price withheld at closing, a prepayment against your actual capital-gains tax that you reclaim only by filing a U.S. tax return ([KE Team Hawaii](https://keteamhawaii.com/blog/what-you-need-to-know-about-hawaiis-real-estate-withholding-tax-when-selling)). That withholding is based on gross price, not profit, so it applies even to a sale at a loss. ## A county takeover is the main wildcard for the condos The single biggest variable for a buyer is who ends up running the water. At the October PUC hearing, the utility's attorney said Hawaii County — which is in the process of purchasing the nearby Punaluʻu Black Sand Beach Park, also owned by Liu — had expressed interest in taking over the water and wastewater infrastructure, though he called it **"still in preliminary discussions"** ([Hawaii Tribune-Herald](https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/2026/10/21/hawaii-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)). A county takeover would change the math: a municipal utility has a public mandate and access to capital that a private operator in financial trouble does not. Without it, the restoration path is slow and costly. The utility's attorney said building a new well site is not a possible solution: the quickest route to a drilling permit is nine months, and he put exploration to find the water site at roughly **$1.5 million, not counting the drilling itself**. Even after the storm, the working wellhead may be contaminated, which could add another three months to bring chlorine levels back to safe ranges ([Big Island Now](https://bigislandnow.com/2026/10/04/nearly-100-customers-still-without-drinking-water-and-sewer-after-lala-damaged-private-punalu%CA%BBu-utility)). The PUC, which received its first documented complaint just two days after the storm, has been pressing for a restoration plan; by Oct. 1 it said none had been filed. ## The takeover scenarios: municipal vs. private Whether a county takeover happens is the hinge that decides whether Punaluu condos are a distressed bargain or a money pit. **A municipal water utility would bring a public mandate and access to capital; a continued private or receivership model almost certainly means higher rates, special assessments, and years of uncertainty.** For a buyer, the stakes are direct: HOA fees and occupancy — the two numbers that drive condo value — move with who runs the water. The groundwork for a takeover is real but unfinished. Hawaii County is already buying the neighboring Punaluʻu Black Sand Beach Park from Liu, and at the October PUC hearing, PWS attorney Colin Sakumoto said the county had expressed interest in taking over the water and wastewater infrastructure because it believes it is better suited to maintain it — though he called the talks still in preliminary discussions ([Hawaii Tribune-Herald](https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/2026/10/21/hawaii-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)). There is a second path: residents of the roughly 96–100 affected homes, organized as the Ninole Wai Community Association, want to take over ownership, operation, control and maintenance of the systems themselves — the association's president, Jeff Silva, said the community body has a direct stake in the outcome and can run the systems ([West Hawaii Today](https://www.westhawaiitoday.com/2026/10/21/top-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)). The private-status quo is already expensive and getting worse. In 2025 the PUC approved a roughly 3,000% temporary yearlong rate increase for PWS customers to fund maintenance, and in May 2026 extended it for another year — yet residents said they saw no visible improvements, and Silva said the water tank leaks so badly that without pumping every three days there is no water in the tank ([West Hawaii Today](https://www.westhawaiitoday.com/2026/10/21/top-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)). The utility has no insurance, could not afford a portable water tank, and has not reached an agreement with any water hauler on the island. If the county does not step in, the realistic path is a PUC-driven receivership or a mandated community takeover — either of which would land the repair and operating costs on the same residents who already fund the system. For a buyer, the two scenarios look very different on the metrics that matter. Scenario How it plays out What it means for buyers **County takeover** Hawaii County acquires the system as part of its Black Sand Beach Park purchase and restores water with public funds, using bond-backed capital and a municipal mandate ([Hawaii Tribune-Herald](https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/2026/10/21/hawaii-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)) Service returns on a defined schedule; occupancy and rental income recover; HOA fees stable once utility costs are normalized — the closest thing to a clean path to recovery and value appreciation **Private status quo** PWS stays in charge with no money, no insurance and no timeline; rates stay at the PUC-approved elevated level ([West Hawaii Today](https://www.westhawaiitoday.com/2026/10/21/top-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)) Condos stay uninhabitable as rentals; HOA and special assessments rise as owners fund tanks and porta-potties; occupancy and resale value stay depressed — the distressed price reflects a genuine, unresolved liability **Community/receivership takeover** Ninole Wai Community Association or a court-appointed receiver takes over ownership and operation of the systems, funded by the owners themselves ([West Hawaii Today](https://www.westhawaiitoday.com/2026/10/21/top-news/we-cant-manage-much-longer-puc-holds-meeting-regarding-broken-punaluu-water-system)) Service can return, but the repair bill is paid through direct assessments on every owner; a foreign buyer inherits a share of that liability before any occupancy income returns ## Advice for investors weighing Punaluu If a discounted Punaluu condo is on your radar, treat the water system as the first question, not an afterthought. **Confirm in writing who owns and operates the utility, whether it is insured, whether a county or state takeover is actively underway, and whether the condo association carries reserves** — the last one matters because the storm left owners relying on personal credit cards and private tank purchases. Model the worst case before the best one. Assume zero rental income for a full year, budget for the HARPTA and FIRPTA withholdings on any eventual sale, and verify with a Hawaii-based CPA what your effective tax liability would be. The opportunity in Punaluu is real only if the infrastructure risk is solved — and as of late October 2026, it is not. A buyer who prices that in can find a long-term value; one who does not is buying a water outage.