If I were paying $2,100 a month in rent and looking at a $400,000 starter home in Salt Lake County, I would answer one question before I called a lender. How much more would I pay to own this place, and what would I get for the difference?
On the assumptions below, renting wins on cash for the first several years. Buying wins on stability, control and whatever the home is worth when you sell. Which one you pick depends on how long you plan to stay and how much of your savings you are willing to put into the house.
I ran the comparison for a Salt Lake County renter with $2,100 rent, $48,000 in cash to close, and a 10% down payment on a $400,000 home at a hypothetical 6.50% rate. The monthly gap lands around $1,025. Over three years, renting comes out about $56,000 cheaper. Over five years, about $70,500 cheaper. The homeowner's equity does not close that gap unless the home sells for more than the purchase price.
Those numbers assume flat rent, no appreciation and 6% selling costs. Change any of the three and the answer moves. Here is the math, in the order I would run it.
What do the two options actually cost?
The matrix below answers the buyer concerns that decide this call, not a list of house features. Read the first two rows if you only read two.
Buyer concern | Renewing the lease at $2,100 | Buying the $400,000 starter home |
|---|---|---|
What leaves your account each month | $2,100, with no separate bill for repairs or taxes | About $3,125, counting principal, interest, taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance, HOA dues and a maintenance budget |
Cash required on day one | A deposit, typically equal to one month's rent | About $48,000, including the down payment, closing costs and prepaid expenses |
Best for | A household that may move within three years, wants savings for goals other than a house, or needs a rental that a starter home cannot match | A household that plans to stay, wants a fixed payment and is willing to hold through a soft market |
Main limitation | Rent can rise at renewal, and the lease can end when the owner decides | Selling within a few years usually costs more than the equity the buyer has built |
Who carries repair risk | The landlord pays for the roof, furnace and water heater | The owner pays for every repair, including the ones insurance will not cover |
How the payment changes over time | Rent resets at each renewal and tracks the local rental market | A fixed-rate principal and interest payment stays the same, while taxes and insurance still rise |
What you keep at the end | Nothing beyond whatever you saved or invested along the way | The sale proceeds after the loan payoff and selling costs |
Nothing in that table settles the question by itself. The next sections put numbers behind the rows that matter most, starting with the monthly payment.
How much more would owning cost each month?
About $1,025 a month, once you count the bills that arrive outside the mortgage payment. On a hypothetical 30-year fixed loan at 6.50% with 10% down, a $400,000 home means borrowing $360,000 and paying roughly $2,275 a month in principal and interest. The mortgage is the smallest part of the difference, which is why comparing rent to a principal and interest quote leads people to the wrong answer.
Monthly expense | Rent | Buy |
|---|---|---|
Rent or mortgage principal and interest | $2,100 | $2,275 |
Property taxes and homeowners insurance | — | $350 |
Private mortgage insurance | — | $125 |
HOA dues | — | $125 |
Maintenance budget | — | $250 |
Total monthly housing budget | $2,100 | $3,125 |
Private mortgage insurance appears because the down payment is under 20%. The CFPB notes that buyers who put down less than 20% likely pay for mortgage insurance, and that it adds to the monthly cost. Property taxes and insurance usually come bundled into the payment through an escrow account, so the number you see on your loan estimate is not the number that leaves your account.
The maintenance line is the one buyers most often skip. The CFPB's homebuyer readiness checklist asks whether you can set aside money for repairs and improvements on top of the mortgage, insurance and taxes. A leaky faucet is a Saturday. A failed water heater or a roof is a four-figure bill with no landlord to call.
Utilities and renters insurance sit outside this table on both sides, and they are not equal. A house generally costs more to heat, cool and insure than an apartment of similar square footage, so add your own quotes before you trust the $1,025 gap.
Mini-verdict: Owning costs more per month in almost every Salt Lake County case I have priced. The real question is whether the extra $1,025 buys something you value.
How much cash would buying tie up?
The estimate here is $48,000: $40,000 down plus about $8,000 for closing costs and prepaid expenses. That is the number that decides more first purchases than the interest rate does.
Utah buyers have lower-down-payment paths. The Utah Homeownership Authority's buyer FAQ lists 3% down on a conventional loan and 3.5% on FHA, and notes that down payment assistance programs are available statewide. A smaller down payment frees up cash, raises the monthly payment and usually adds mortgage insurance.
Before you commit $48,000, answer one question. After closing, moving and the first round of repairs, how many months of expenses would you still have in the bank? If the answer is under three, I would shop at a lower price or wait.
What would three years or five years actually cost?
Renting costs about $56,000 less over three years and $70,500 less over five, once the homeowner gets credit for equity. That is the finding most rent-versus-buy calculators bury, and it is the one that matters if your timeline is short.
The assumptions are deliberately conservative in the buyer's favor. Rent stays flat at $2,100. The home sells for the original $400,000. Selling costs are 6% of the price, which is an example for budgeting rather than a quote, so ask for a seller net sheet before you rely on it. The full maintenance budget counts as spent.
Estimated result | After 3 years | After 5 years |
|---|---|---|
Rent paid | $75,600 | $126,000 |
Buyer cash spent upfront and during ownership | $160,500 | $235,500 |
Cash back to buyer at sale, after selling costs and loan payoff | $28,900 | $39,000 |
Net cost of buying, owning, and selling | $131,600 | $196,500 |
The homeowner's advantage grows with time because each payment shifts more toward principal. In the first years, most of a mortgage payment is interest, so the equity you build is thin relative to the cash you put in. That is the mechanism behind the gap, and it is why a three-year hold is the hardest case for buying.
The CFPB makes the same point from the other direction. Its guide to the financial considerations of buying says buying and selling a home are expensive processes involving lots of fees, taxes and commissions, and that you want to stay long enough for those costs to be worth it. The same page warns that if prices fall, you may not be able to move after a few years because you could owe more than the house is worth.
That warning is not theoretical in Utah. The Kem C. Gardner Policy Institute's 2026 housing report puts the statewide median sale price at $520,000 in the first quarter of 2026, up from $500,000 a year earlier, and describes the current stretch as stable growth after a record run. Stable growth is better for a five-year hold than a spike, but it also means you should not count on a quick price jump to rescue a short one.
Mini-verdict: If a move within three years is plausible, renting is the cheaper financial choice on these numbers. Buying starts to compete when you can hold five years or more and the payment fits comfortably.
Where does Salt Lake County's market change the math?
Utah's affordability picture is tighter than the statewide averages suggest, and that cuts against the first-time buyer in a way the monthly table does not show. The Kem C. Gardner Policy Institute's 2026 housing report estimates the annual income needed to buy Utah's median-priced home at $147,000 in the first half of 2026, and reports that only 4.9% of homes sold in 2025 were affordable to a renter household earning the median renter income of $64,000. Roughly 91% of Utah renters are priced out of the median home at current rates.
That statistic frames the $400,000 starter home correctly. It is not the median Utah home, and finding one in Salt Lake County takes work. Gardner's report notes that smaller homes and smaller lots are what make newer housing more affordable, and that about 26.1% of homes sold in 2025 were affordable to households at 100% of the area median income.
The rental side is moving in two directions at once. From March 2024 to March 2026, average asking rent across Utah's five most populated counties rose 8.5% for single-family detached homes and 8.3% for townhomes, while apartment asking rents fell 2.3%, according to the same Gardner report. If you rent a house today, your renewal is more likely to rise than fall. If you rent an apartment, the opposite may be true.
For a Salt Lake County renter, that split matters more than any national rent-versus-buy figure. A renter in a single-family home faces real renewal risk, which strengthens the case for locking a payment. A renter in an apartment building has more leverage at renewal than the headlines imply.
What happens if the home sells for more than you paid?
A 10% price gain changes the answer less than most buyers expect. If the $400,000 home sells for $440,000 after five years, the buyer nets about $37,600 more at sale once the assumed 6% selling costs come out of the higher price. That narrows the five-year cost gap from about $70,500 to about $32,900. Renting still costs less.
Run the price gain higher and the gap keeps shrinking, because the homeowner's equity compounds while the renter's does not. Run it lower, or flat, and the gap widens. Buying is a bet on your holding period and on the price, and the mortgage payment is only the entry fee.
Three other variables move the result as much as price does.
Rent increases. A $2,100 rent that rises 5% at renewal is $2,205 in year two and $2,315 in year three. Over three years that adds roughly $5,000 to the renting side and closes part of the gap.
A major repair. A furnace, roof or sewer line lands on the homeowner's side only. A single five-figure repair inside three years can erase the buyer's entire equity position.
A lower rate or a bigger down payment. Both reduce the monthly payment and the interest share of it, which speeds up the principal the buyer keeps. Neither changes the fact that selling costs come out of the proceeds.
Rerun the table with your own renewal offer and your own rate before you decide. A comparison built on someone else's assumptions cannot guide your choice.
What does each option genuinely do worse?
Renting's real weakness is that you do not control your payment or your address. The lease ends when the owner decides, renewal terms arrive on the landlord's schedule, and nothing you pay builds an asset. A renter who stays twenty years in the same unit owns nothing at the end of it.
Buying's real weakness is that it converts liquid savings into an illiquid asset with high transaction costs on both ends. The CFPB points out that buying and selling a home are expensive processes involving lots of fees, taxes and commissions, and that the money is hard to recover quickly if your plans change. A soft market makes that worse, since you may owe more than the house is worth at exactly the moment you need to move.
There is a quieter cost on the buying side that rarely shows up in comparisons. A $400,000 starter home in Salt Lake County usually needs something, whether a roof in its last third, a dated kitchen, or a furnace older than the buyer. Budgeting $250 a month for maintenance smooths that over time, but the bills do not arrive on a monthly schedule.
And renting has a quiet advantage the math above excludes. The $48,000 you do not put into a house can stay invested or stay available. The three-year table gives the homeowner credit for equity but gives the renter nothing for the cash they keep, which understates the renter's position.
Choose renting if, choose buying if
Choose to keep renting if a job change could take you out of Salt Lake County within three years, your savings after closing would drop below three months of expenses, the $400,000 homes you can find need more work than you can fund, or your rent is in an apartment building where asking rents have been flat or falling.
Choose to buy if you can hold five years or more, the full monthly payment fits without straining the rest of your budget, you have reserves left after closing, and the home solves something a rental cannot, such as a yard, a garage, or a shorter commute. If you are a veteran, price a VA loan before you assume the down payment is out of reach, since the Utah Homeownership Authority lists 0% down and no monthly mortgage insurance on that program.
For the household in the middle, the decision usually comes down to one question. Would you rather pay about $1,025 a month for control of your address and a shot at equity, or keep that money and stay flexible? Neither answer is wrong. The one that is wrong is buying a three-year house on a five-year plan.
1Is the $3,125 monthly figure realistic for every Salt Lake County home?
No. It is a national average of what buyers pay, and Salt Lake County property tax rates, insurance premiums and HOA dues set your actual number. Ask for a loan estimate and a property-specific insurance quote before you compare.
2Can I buy with less than 10% down and keep my savings?
You can, but you will likely pay mortgage insurance until the loan balance falls below 80% of the home's value, and you will need to confirm the program and any assistance rules with a lender. The tradeoff is a higher payment in exchange for keeping reserves.
3What if I need to sell sooner than three years?
Selling costs, usually paid out of the proceeds, come off the top. At the 6% example used here, a $400,000 sale costs about $24,000 before the loan payoff, which is why the first few years of payments build so little net equity.
4Does my equity grow at the same pace every year?
Part of each payment goes to principal, so your loan balance falls every month. On a $360,000 loan at 6.50%, the principal portion starts small and grows slowly, which is why equity builds faster in years four and five than in years one and two.
The CFPB's list of financial considerations for buyers covers the rows that carry the most weight. Property taxes, insurance and utilities can cost more than a renter pays today and are likely to increase over the course of the mortgage. Repairs run from a leaky faucet to a replaced roof, which is why an emergency fund belongs in the plan.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!