VOCE
S
LoginStart Creating
Loading…
VOCE

The publishing platform for a more visible, trusted, and valuable professional presence.

VOH-chay is Italian for “voice.” Every expert has one worth hearing.

VOX is Latin for “voice,” too. He writes with you, answers your questions and shows you what to do next.

Platform

OwnershipDiscoveryMomentumExplore Content

Solutions

AuthorsBrandsAgenciesStart Writing

© VOCE. All rights reserved.

  • What We Do
  • Who We Are
  • Plans
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Legal
    End of article
    • 0 Likes
    • 0 Comments
    • 0 Questions
    • 0 Shares
    • 8 Views

    Discussion

    No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

    Q&A with the Author

    V
    Virginia Fargo

    @virginiafargo

    INDEPENDENT MORTGAGE BROKER #299320

    Empire Home Loans

    Virginia Fargo, NMLS #299320, is an independent mortgage broker with Empire Home Loans, providing No Hassle Home Loans in Scottsdale, Phoenix, Maricopa County, and across Arizona. With 15+ years of mortgage experience, Virginia specializes in first-time homebuyers, relocation, affordability, self-employed borrowers, FHA, VA, conventional, down payment assistance, bank statement, jumbo, DSCR, manufactured home loans, refinancing, HELOCs, and home equity solutions. She helps consumers understand how much home they can afford, improve their path to mortgage approval, and find financing solutions for unique credit, income, and financial situations.

    19 Articles1 Followers
    More from Virginia
    V
    Virginia Fargo
    @virginiafargo
    Trending
    1. Read
    2. Topics
    3. Property & Real Estate
    4. Sell or Stay? What a 3% Mortgage Really Costs Phoenix Homeowners
    17 min
    Sell or Stay? What a 3% Mortgage Really Costs Phoenix Homeowners
    Property & Real Estate

    Sell or Stay? What a 3% Mortgage Really Costs Phoenix Homeowners

    VVirginia Fargo
    November 19, 2026

    For most Maricopa County homeowners who bought or refinanced before 2022, the answer depends on the house, not the rate. Stay if the home still fits your life and you have reserves for the roof and the HVAC. Move if it does not, because your equity, not your 3% rate, usually decides the outcome. A 3% mortgage is not a reason to stay in a house that no longer fits your life. It is one line on a spreadsheet, and most Phoenix and Scottsdale homeowners holding a loan from 2020 or 2021 are reading that line in isolation while ignoring the four or five others that matter more.

    That gap is real. It is also smaller, in monthly dollars, than most people assume. If selling and buying would improve your housing situation, your equity is usually large enough to absorb the payment difference. If your current home still works, staying is often the smarter financial call. The rest of this article shows you how to tell which one you are.

    I have written home loans in Maricopa County for 15 years. In that time I have watched homeowners talk themselves out of moves that would have improved their finances and their daily lives, and I have watched others wait for a rate that never came.

    This is an educational analysis, not a loan offer or a promise of any outcome. Rates, terms, and eligibility vary.

    Desert suburban neighborhood at sunset, representing Scottsdale-area housing

    Which path fits your situation?

    The table below maps common homeowner situations to the decision that usually fits, along with the tradeoff you accept by choosing it. Read your row before you read anything else.

    Your situation

    What the math usually shows

    Best for

    Main limitation

    Home no longer fits; strong equity position

    Equity covers a larger down payment, which shrinks the new loan and softens the payment jump

    Families who bought before 2021 and need space, a different school zone, or a shorter commute

    You trade a low fixed rate for a higher one and give up the certainty of the old payment

    Retirement or downsizing on the horizon

    Selling frees equity and can lower total monthly outlay even at a higher rate

    Homeowners in North Scottsdale, Fountain Hills, or larger foothills properties

    Smaller or single-level homes are in tight supply, which limits negotiating room

    Home still works; payment is comfortable

    The cost of moving outweighs the benefit; the low rate compounds in your favor

    Anyone with no pressing lifestyle or financial reason to move

    You accept that deferred maintenance and rising ownership costs will arrive eventually

    Rate is low but the loan is FHA or VA

    Your existing rate may transfer to a buyer through an assumption

    Sellers whose buyer can cover the equity gap in cash

    Assumable loans close slowly and require buyer qualification and servicer approval

    You want to move but hesitate to sell

    Renting the current home out may preserve the low rate

    Owners with enough equity, reserves, and rental demand in their submarket

    Rental income, reserves, and financing rules must all support it; this is not passive

    You need cash, not a new house

    A second lien may access equity without touching the first mortgage

    Owners who need funds but want to keep the 3% first loan intact

    A second lien adds debt and a second payment; eligibility and terms vary

    Key Takeaways

    • The average top-tier 30-year fixed rate reached 7.51% in mid-November, more than four points above the rate many Valley homeowners locked in before 2022.
    • In the fourth quarter of 2025, 45.4% of mortgaged Arizona homes were equity-rich, meaning loan balances sat at half the property's value or less.
    • Greater Phoenix has more supply than a year ago, which gives buyers negotiating room and sellers a harder pricing job.
    • The right question is not what rate you have, but what staying costs versus moving, in total dollars.

    Why does a 3% rate feel impossible to give up?

    Because the gap between your rate and today's rate is large, and because loss aversion makes that gap feel like a loss you would be choosing. The feeling is legitimate. The dollar figure behind it is usually smaller than the feeling suggests.

    Rates have been volatile all autumn. The Mortgage Bankers Association's weekly survey showed the 30-year fixed at 7.21% for the week ending Nov. 6, when rates briefly dipped before climbing again (Mortgage News Daily). That week-to-week swing matters: anyone waiting for a specific number to arrive on a specific day is making a bet on bond markets that even professional forecasters get wrong routinely.

    That volatility matters. Rates moved roughly a third of a point in a single week. Anyone waiting for a specific number to arrive on a specific day is making a bet on bond markets that even professional forecasters get wrong routinely.

    Here is the part homeowners rarely calculate. The rate gap is real, but the loan you would take on after a move is rarely the same size as the one you hold now. If you have lived in your home for five or six years, your equity reduces that balance substantially. A much higher rate applied to a much smaller loan produces a payment increase far smaller than the rate comparison implies.

    Take a homeowner who sold and cleared $300,000 in equity, then bought again at a similar price. That household would be financing a balance $300,000 smaller than the one it started with, and today's rate would be charged against that smaller number rather than the old one.

    That is the arithmetic behind the decision. Not the rate, the rate times the balance.

    What is happening in the Phoenix and Scottsdale market right now?

    Buyers in Greater Phoenix have more choices than they did a year ago, and sellers are learning to price for it. Both facts change the sell-versus-stay calculation in ways a national rate article cannot capture.

    In Old Town Scottsdale, the median sale price was $598,714 over the three months ending October 2026, up 7.1% year over year, and homes sold after a median of 81 days on market (Redfin). The average home there sold about 4% below list price. That is a market where well-priced homes move and optimistic ones sit.

    The picture varies sharply by submarket. Zillow's home value index put the average DC Ranch home at $2,544,537, up 5.1% over the past year (Zillow). Luxury pockets in North Scottsdale have held value while entry-level segments have softened.

    Nationally, existing-home sales in October fell to their lowest pace since 2010 as buyers adjusted to elevated rates, with unsold supply reaching a 5.1-month level and homes spending a median of 35 days on market (NAR). That is close to balanced. Balanced markets reward preparation over urgency.

    What this means for you: if you are selling, price against recent closed sales in your own ZIP code, not against a neighbor's asking price. If you are buying, more inventory means more room to negotiate price, concessions, or a rate buydown. Both advantages are available to the same household that moves carefully.

    How much equity do Maricopa County homeowners actually have?

    More than most people realize, even after a year of softening values. That equity is the asset that makes a move possible without waiting for a lower rate.

    In the fourth quarter of 2025, 45.4% of mortgaged homes in Arizona were equity-rich, meaning the combined loan balance was no more than half the property's estimated value, down from 50.9% a year earlier (ATTOM). Arizona still sat well above the national 44.6% figure, and the state's decline tracked the broader national pullback from the 2024 peak rather than a Valley-specific collapse.

    Put plainly: if you bought or refinanced before 2021, there is a reasonable chance your loan-to-value ratio is below 50%. On a home now worth $600,000, that means roughly $300,000 or more of usable equity.

    Equity does three jobs at once. It covers a larger down payment, which reduces the new loan balance. It can eliminate mortgage insurance when program requirements are met. And it can absorb closing costs and moving expenses without draining savings. That is why a rate comparison alone misleads: a homeowner carrying a small loan against a well-appreciated house is not financing the same balance they financed in 2019.

    That is why the rate comparison alone misleads. A homeowner with $300,000 of equity is not financing the same balance they financed in 2019.

    Dramatic sunset over a suburban landscape

    What does staying actually cost over time?

    Staying is not free. It carries expenses that do not appear on a rate sheet, and those expenses tend to arrive in clusters rather than spread evenly. Home prices have stayed resilient even as sales slowed, which means sellers have room to negotiate but not room to overprice (NAR). The table below sets the two paths side by side using cost categories rather than precise quotes, since your roof, your HVAC, and your HOA are yours alone.

    Cost category

    If you stay

    If you move

    Monthly principal and interest

    Fixed at your existing rate on your existing balance

    Likely higher, offset by a smaller balance funded from equity

    Roof, HVAC, and major systems

    You own the next replacement on a house that is aging

    Resets to the age of the home you buy, so verify age before you close

    Cooling and utilities

    Summer cooling on a floor plan built for a family that may no longer live there

    Scaled to the home you actually need, which can fall noticeably after downsizing

    Property tax, insurance, and HOA

    Rising independent of your rate, and insurance in Arizona has been repricing

    Resets to the new property's assessed value, coverage, and association dues

    Commute and transportation

    Unchanged, including any time and fuel the current location demands

    Depends entirely on where you land; a shorter commute is a real, recurring saving

    Transaction costs

    Zero, until a deferred repair forces a rushed decision

    Selling costs, moving costs, and financing costs, all paid once

    Read the third column honestly. Moving is not free, and anyone who tells you it is has not added up the whole bill. The point of the table is that the stay column is not zero either. It is simply easier to ignore.

    A roof replacement, a failed HVAC unit, and a pool resurfacing inside the same two years can consume more cash than the monthly payment difference on a modest move. That math does not always favor moving. It does always deserve a calculation before you decide.

    Can a buyer take over your low rate?

    Sometimes. FHA and VA mortgages are generally assumable, which means a qualified buyer may be able to take over your existing loan at your existing rate instead of financing at today's levels. That is a genuine marketing advantage in a market where the average 30-year fixed sits above 7% (Mortgage News Daily).

    The mechanics matter more than the headline. The buyer must qualify for the assumption under the program's requirements. The buyer must also cover the difference between the purchase price and your remaining loan balance using cash or acceptable additional financing, which is where many assumptions stall. VA sellers should understand the difference between release of liability and restoration of VA entitlement, because those are separate outcomes with separate consequences.

    Most conventional loans are not freely assumable. If you hold a conventional loan at 3%, an assumption is unlikely to be available to your buyer, and your equity-based strategy becomes the center of the conversation instead.

    I raise assumptions early with sellers because they change pricing strategy. A listing that advertises an assumable sub-4% loan draws a different buyer pool than one that does not.

    Should you wait for rates to fall?

    Waiting is a decision with a cost, and that cost is rarely written down. The honest answer is that no one can promise a future rate, and anyone who does is guessing about bond markets.

    The October data shows how fast conditions shift. The 30-year rate averaged 7.33% for the month, up from 6.25% a year earlier, a jump that added about $216 per month to payments on a $300,000 mortgage (NAR). Rates climbed above 7% in late September for the first time in more than a year and have stayed elevated since.

    The market you would be selling into is changing too. Existing-home sales fell 5.5% in October from September and were down 8.8% annually, with about 20.5% of active listings taking price reductions, the highest for the month since 2022 (NAR). More competing listings means more pressure on your asking price if you wait.

    There is a version of waiting that makes sense. If your home still fits your life, your payment is comfortable, and you have reserves for maintenance, staying is often the financially superior choice, and a 3% rate compounds in your favor every month you hold it. I tell clients that directly.

    What I push back on is waiting as a default. If the reason you want to move is a growing family, a retirement plan, a commute that costs you two hours a day, or a house you can no longer maintain, then waiting is not a neutral choice. It is an active choice to keep paying for a problem while hoping a rate arrives to solve it.

    The compromise many homeowners miss: you can move now and refinance later if rates fall. Rates, terms, and eligibility vary, and no one can guarantee a future refinance will be available or advantageous. But a refinance is a possibility you keep open. A missed year in a home that does not work is gone.

    Choose A if, choose B if

    Most homeowners arrive at my desk already knowing what they want and looking for permission. The permission structure below is organized by situation rather than by preference, and the equity figure that anchors it comes from a market where 45.4% of mortgaged Arizona homes were equity-rich in the fourth quarter of 2025 (ATTOM).

    Choose to stay if your home still fits your daily life, your payment is comfortable, and you have set aside reserves for the roof, the HVAC, and the next major repair. In that case the low rate is doing exactly what it should: lowering your housing cost while your equity grows. There is no prize for moving.

    Choose to move if the home no longer works and the gap is costing you something measurable, whether that is two hours of commuting, a bedroom you do not have, or a maintenance load you can no longer carry. Run the numbers with your equity included, then decide. Most homeowners in this group find the payment difference smaller than they feared.

    Choose to keep and rent if your equity, reserves, and rental demand support it and you are prepared for the work of being a landlord. Holding a 3% loan on a property that cash-flows is a legitimate strategy. It is also a business decision, not a loophole, and it should be modeled before it is chosen.

    Choose to pause if none of the above fits yet. Pausing is a decision too, and it is the right one more often than the internet suggests.

    A note for real estate agents

    If you are an agent in Scottsdale, Phoenix, or anywhere in Maricopa County, you are having this conversation weekly, and the client usually arrives with a conclusion already formed. Here is how I handle it, and you are welcome to borrow any of it.

    Name the number before they do. Ask what their current payment is, what their loan balance is, and what their home would likely sell for today. Most clients have never put those three figures in the same sentence. The gap between fear and arithmetic closes quickly once they do.

    Separate the rate from the payment. A client at 3% comparing to 7.5% is comparing the wrong figures. Show them the payment on the balance they would actually carry after their equity is applied. That comparison is the one that changes minds, in either direction.

    Flag assumability early. If your seller holds an FHA or VA loan, an assumption may widen the buyer pool. If it is conventional, say so plainly and pivot to the equity story. Either way, get the loan type confirmed before the listing goes live, because it shapes your pricing and marketing.

    Use the inventory data in your pricing conversation. With about 20.5% of active listings taking price reductions in October, the highest for the month since 2022, a seller who prices for a market that no longer exists will spend the listing period chasing it (NAR).

    Bring me in before the offer, not after. Pre-approval conversations are where the strategy gets set. I will run scenarios on a client's equity position, compare loan structures, and give you a realistic payment range before your buyer falls in love with a house they cannot comfortably afford. That saves everyone a difficult conversation later.

    You can reach me directly at 480-262-4024, or book time on my calendar whenever a client conversation needs a second set of numbers.

    The bottom line

    Your rate is one line on the page. Your equity, your payment, your maintenance costs, and the life you are actually living occupy the rest of it. I have never met a homeowner who regretted running the math before deciding. I have met plenty who regretted deciding without it.

    If you would like a personalized analysis of your situation, I am glad to walk through it with you. No pressure, no pitch, just the numbers for your home and your goals.

    Book a call with Virginia Fargo

    This article is educational and does not constitute a loan offer, commitment to lend, or guarantee of approval, rates, or savings. Rates, terms, and eligibility vary. Consult a licensed mortgage professional about your specific circumstances.

    Virginia Fargo, providing No Hassle Home Loans, the trusted mortgage consultant, home loan advisor in Scottsdale & Across Maricopa County, the leading mortgage broker dedicated to helping consumers save money specializing in home loans, first-time homebuyers, relocation, affordability and self-employed borrower financing.


    Contact Virginia Fargo to learn more about your options and get answers to your questions: schedule a call.

    Loan programs and guidelines are subject to change without notice. Not all borrowers or properties will qualify. Loan amounts, LTV, DTI, credit requirements, reserves, income documentation, mortgage insurance and property eligibility are subject to applicable program requirements and underwriting approval. Verify current guidelines before making financing decisions.

    Virginia Fargo | NMLS #299320

    Independent Mortgage Broker | Empire Home Loans

    Serving Phoenix, Scottsdale, North Scottsdale, Fountain Hills, and Arizona homeowners.

    480-262-4024

    No Hassle Home Loans

    Empire Home Loans | NMLS #1839243

    AZ License: MB-1012019

    Equal Housing Lender

    Rates, terms, and eligibility vary.


    Sources

    • Mortgage News Daily, mortgage rate update, Nov. 16, 2026

    • Mortgage News Daily, MBA weekly applications survey, Nov. 13, 2026

    • National Association of Realtors, existing-home sales report, Nov. 12, 2026

    • Redfin, Old Town Scottsdale housing market data, October 2026

    • Zillow, DC Ranch Scottsdale home values

    • ATTOM, Q4 2025 U.S. Home Equity and Underwater Report

    • Virginia Fargo, No Hassle Home Loans: Should I sell my Phoenix home with a 3% mortgage rate?

    V
    Virginia Fargo@virginiafargo
    INDEPENDENT MORTGAGE BROKER #299320Empire Home Loans

    Want to connect with Virginia?

    Ask, follow, or jump into the discussion on this article.

    More from this Author

    Maxed-Out Cards Are Dragging Down Your Credit. Could a Cash-Out Refinance Help?

    Maxed-Out Cards Are Dragging Down Your Credit. Could a Cash-Out Refinance Help?

    Nov 14, 2026
    5 min
    280
    Conventional Mortgages Below 620: Arizona's New Path to Homeownership

    Conventional Mortgages Below 620: Arizona's New Path to Homeownership

    Nov 12, 2026
    5 min
    130
    2026 Midterms: What Homeowners and Agents Need to Know

    2026 Midterms: What Homeowners and Agents Need to Know

    Nov 3, 2026
    5 min
    230
    View all 6 articles from Virginia →