The last thing most people want when they need their insurer is to explain their problem to a voice menu. Yet that's exactly what a growing number of carriers deliver — and a 2026 study of 6,000 consumers found 85% of people would rather speak to a real person than an AI system when they contact a business (AnswerConnect). That gap between what companies are automating and what customers actually want is the clearest reason to call an agency that still picks up the phone.
I'm Billy Brown, a State Farm agent in Grosse Pointe Woods, Michigan. When you dial my office, a person answers — not a robot asking you to press one for sales and two for claims. That's a deliberate choice, and in an industry racing toward chatbots and automated claims lines, it's becoming the rarest thing we offer.
Here's my honest position: in insurance, the algorithm is never the luxury. The luxury is a local expert who knows your name, your street, and what a storm actually does to a roof like yours. If your insurer has made you feel like a ticket number, you're paying for protection and getting a call center instead.
Why a policy is impossible to read on your own
Insurance is the one product almost everyone buys but almost no one fully reads. A homeowners policy is a dense contract written to satisfy lawyers, not to be understood by the family paying for it. The gap between what the document says and what it actually covers is where real damage happens — a home that isn't rebuilt to code, a roof that pays out only its depreciated value, a basement claim denied over a line no one flagged.
That's the complexity gap, and it's widening. In Michigan, average homeowners premiums jumped about 21.6% between 2024 and 2025, one of the largest single-year increases in the country, and the forces behind it are compounding — severe wind and hail now drive nearly 40% of the state's home claims, rebuilding costs keep climbing, and reinsurance has gotten pricier (Finlan Insurance). A chatbot can tell you your premium went up. It cannot tell you that your roof just crossed the 15-year mark that several major carriers now use as a trigger to switch to depreciated, actual-cash-value coverage.
That's the difference a person makes. When a client calls worried about a renewal, the conversation isn't about pushing buttons — it's about walking through what changed, why their rate moved, and what they can actually do about it, from bundling policies to keeping a documented condition report on an aging roof. An algorithm routes your question; an agent translates your coverage.
The local advantage an algorithm will never have
An algorithm knows your ZIP code as a risk bucket. A neighbor knows your actual street, your home's age, and the specific weather that's been hammering southeast Michigan. That difference matters more as the state's risk profile shifts — a July 2026 squall line knocked out power to roughly 400,000 southeast Michigan customers, and an April storm triggered a federal disaster declaration across 43 counties (Finlan Insurance).
Living here changes how I think about coverage. The freeze-thaw cycles that age Michigan shingles, the lake-effect wind exposure, the older housing stock along the Pointes — these aren't abstract statistics to me, they're the properties I insure every day. When a client asks whether their dwelling limit is still high enough, I'm not reading from a national underwriting script. I'm comparing their home to the ones around it and to the cost of rebuilding in this market, where construction and labor expenses have risen sharply since 2020.
A phone tree can quote you a number. It can't tell you your neighbor three houses down just filed a wind-and-hail claim that should prompt you to check your own deductible. That kind of insight is the product of being in one community for years, not of a model trained on a million ZIP codes. It's knowledge you literally cannot get from an automated system, because it never existed in its database.
No robots allowed: what a real person actually delivers
Here's the practical truth about automated customer service: it frustrates the people it's supposed to help. In the same 2026 study, 59% of consumers said they find AI agents frustrating when they call customer service, and 31% would hang up entirely if connected to an AI (AnswerConnect). Worse, 36% feel their time is wasted explaining a problem to an automated system only to be transferred to a human who makes them repeat it.
Insurance calls are high-stakes by nature. When a tree comes through a roof or a car gets hit in the driveway, the person on the other end of the line isn't looking for a menu — they need to know their family is protected and the process is moving. A scripted bot can collect a claim number. It can't reassure a homeowner who's standing in a flooded basement, or flag that a policy might not cover the specific loss they just described, or tell them what to document before the adjuster arrives.
That emotional intelligence is a real service, and it's what a person provides that no model can replicate. The 2026 survey found 71% of consumers believe human agents show more empathy and caring than AI in support scenarios (AnswerConnect). When you call my office, you get that on the first ring — someone who's heard it before, knows the next step, and can say your name.
The honest counterargument
I should steel-man the other side, because automation does do some things well. It's fast, it's available at 2 a.m., and for routine questions about claim status or billing due dates, a well-built system can answer in seconds without a wait. Carriers deploy AI precisely because it resolves simple, repetitive calls at a fraction of the cost, and for those calls the efficiency is real. Nobody wants to hold for ten minutes to learn a payment already went through.
So the question isn't whether automation has a place. It's whether the things automation is worst at — interpreting complex coverage, reading local risk, and handling a high-stakes claim with empathy — are the things a policyholder should trust to a phone tree. My answer is no, and the stakes of getting it wrong are too high to gamble on a script. A bot that answers a billing question well is a convenience. A bot that misreads a roof-loss policy at the moment of a claim is a financial disaster for a family.
That's why we keep a person at the other end of the line. Automation will handle the simple stuff; we'd rather be the ones you reach for everything that matters. You can have speed elsewhere. What you can't replace — and what no algorithm can promise — is someone who treats your coverage like their own family's protection.
The choice is yours
Here's what I'd ask you to consider the next time you renew. If your current insurer makes you navigate an automated system just to ask about your own policy, that friction isn't a minor annoyance — it's a signal about how they'll treat you at the moment you actually need them. When the tree hits the roof or the basement floods, you don't want to be forty minutes into a phone tree explaining yourself to a machine.
I built my office in Grosse Pointe Woods on the opposite idea. Call us, and a person answers. We'll review your coverage together, explain what it actually protects, and make sure your dwelling limit still matches the cost of rebuilding your home today. That's the service insurance was always supposed to be — and it's the one thing no algorithm can sell you.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!