VOCE
S
LoginStart Creating
Loading…
VOCE

The publishing platform for a more visible, trusted, and valuable professional presence.

VOH-chay is Italian for “voice.” Every expert has one worth hearing.

VOX is Latin for “voice,” too. He writes with you, answers your questions and shows you what to do next.

Platform

OwnershipDiscoveryMomentumExplore Content

Solutions

AuthorsBrandsAgenciesStart Writing

© VOCE. All rights reserved.

  • What We Do
  • Who We Are
  • Plans
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Legal
    End of article
    • 0 Likes
    • 0 Comments
    • 0 Questions
    • 0 Shares
    • 1 Views

    Discussion

    No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

    Q&A with the Author

    B
    Brandon Lucas

    @brandonlucas

    Real Estate Advisor

    Realty One Group MVP

    Brandon is a Florida native and grew up in the South West Florida Area. His local knowledge gives him a great understanding of the area and the communities that make it. Brandon graduated from USF Tampa with a Business Finance degree. He has worked as a Financial Advisor at US Sugar and as a Customer Sales Specialist. Brandon's finance background, negotiating abilities, and people skills led him to a career in Real Estate. Brandon provide extensive advertising to ensure you get the most value ou

    3 Articles0 Followers
    More from Brandon
    B
    Brandon Lucas
    @brandonlucas
    Trending

    More from this Author

    Buying in Southwest Florida: Navigating the 2026 Market

    Buying in Southwest Florida: Navigating the 2026 Market

    Aug 19, 2026
    5 min
    90
    Is the Fort Myers Real Estate Market Finally Turning a Corner?

    Is the Fort Myers Real Estate Market Finally Turning a Corner?

    Jul 20, 2026
    5 min
    90
    Why Isn't My House Selling? 9 Reasons Homes Sit in today's Southwest Florida real estate market

    Why Isn't My House Selling? 9 Reasons Homes Sit in today's Southwest Florida real estate market

    Nov 15, 2026
    12 min read
    00
    View all 3 articles from Brandon →
    1. Read
    2. Topics
    3. Real Estate
    4. Home Selling
    5. Is Now a Good Time to Sell Your Home in Fort Myers?
    12 min
    Is Now a Good Time to Sell Your Home in Fort Myers?

    Photo by Michael Moloney on Unsplash

    Real Estate

    Is Now a Good Time to Sell Your Home in Fort Myers?

    BBrandon Lucas
    November 16, 2026

    Fort Myers home values are down 4.2% over the past year, yet the typical owner who bought before 2022 is still sitting on a substantial gain. That gap — a falling market that has not erased the boom — is the whole answer to whether you should sell now. For most long-tenured Lee County homeowners, the math favors listing sooner rather than waiting for a recovery that the local data does not project.

    I have worked Lee County resales for 12 years, through the 2021–22 frenzy, the post-Hurricane Ian scramble, and the slower, thinner market we are in today. That street-level view matters more than usual right now, because the headline numbers everyone quotes — Cape Coral is the worst market in the country, Florida is crashing — describe timing mistakes, not a collapse. The sellers struggling in late 2026 are largely the ones who bought at the peak and need to move quickly. The sellers doing well are the ones holding pre-boom equity who price to today's comps instead of 2022's.

    Here is the case for and against selling now, with the neighborhoods and property types where the answer flips.

    Key Takeaways

    • Fort Myers home values averaged $304,566 in late September 2026, down 4.2% year over year, with homes taking about 65 days to go pending.
    • Lee County single-family prices are 18.3% below their 2022 peak but still 38.2% above March 2020 — most owners hold real equity.
    • Local analysts at the 2026 Market Trends event expect buyer's-market conditions to persist for several years, not months.
    • Condo owners face a much harder market than single-family owners: Lee County condo prices are down 24.8% from peak.
    • New construction and builder rate buydowns are pulling buyers away from resale homes, so pricing and condition carry more weight than they did in 2022.

    What is the Fort Myers market actually doing in late 2026?

    The typical Fort Myers home was worth $304,566 at the end of September 2026, down 4.2% from a year earlier, and homes were taking roughly 65 days to go pending (Zillow). That is a slow, price-sensitive market — but not a broken one. Buyers are still transacting; they are simply refusing to overpay.

    Fort Myers housing market price and inventory chart

    Zoom out and the picture gets more useful. ResiClub's October 2026 analysis of 35 major Florida counties found that Lee County single-family prices sit 18.3% below their mid-2022 peak while remaining 38.2% above March 2020 (ResiClub). In dollar terms, a hypothetical $300,000 Lee County home climbed to about $507,000 at the peak and has since settled near $415,000. That is a real loss against the top — and a real gain against where most owners bought.

    Local brokers tell the same story with a different emphasis. At the Market Trends 2026 event in downtown Fort Myers, roughly 1,300 industry professionals heard Denny Grimes of Keller Williams argue that the region's downturn is a timing problem, not a collapse, and that median sales prices fell 3%, 2%, and 5% over the past three years after rising 12%, 25%, and 20% during the boom (Gulfshore Business).

    Those annual declines are decelerating, not accelerating — the most important data point for a seller weighing now versus next spring.

    What that means for you: if you bought before 2021, you are almost certainly still in profit and the question is how much of it you keep. If you bought in 2022 or 2023, you may be at or slightly below your purchase price, and the decision shifts from "when do I cash out" to "can I afford to wait."

    Why is inventory the number that decides your outcome?

    Because supply, not demand, is what sets your sale price right now. Buyers in Lee County are plentiful — the region's population is approaching 1 million by Census estimates and tourism spending rebounded 18% to about $3.1 billion (Florida Trend). What has changed is how many alternatives those buyers can choose from on any given weekend.

    Competition now arrives from three directions at once, and each hits a different kind of seller.

    The first is new construction. Builders entered the post-boom market carrying excess inventory, and they solved it the way builders always do — with concessions. ResiClub's analysis notes that builders used mortgage rate buydowns and rental incentives to move product, which pulled buyers who would otherwise have purchased an existing home and pushed resale inventory higher (ResiClub). You cannot out-concede a national builder on closing costs. You can beat them on lot, finish quality, and location — but only if your price makes the comparison worth a buyer's time.

    The second is the growth corridors themselves. At Market Trends 2026, LSI Companies CEO Justin Thibaut flagged eastern Corkscrew Road in Lee County — where the 10,000-home Kingston community broke ground — as a major expansion zone, alongside Burnt Store Road in Charlotte County, which he described as a full-blown builder battleground with D.R. Horton, Taylor Morrison, Neal Communities and others planning thousands of homes (Gulfshore Business). If your home sits near one of those corridors, expect sustained competition for years.

    The third is the distressed layer. Local forecasters expect a rise in distressed properties through 2026, which adds lower-priced inventory to the same buyer pool you are fishing in. That is a reason to sell ahead of the wave rather than behind it.

    Do mortgage rates help or hurt a Fort Myers seller?

    Rates are a headwind on buyer purchasing power but not the deciding factor locally. Mortgage rates ended the third quarter of 2026 at 7.03%, the highest level since the start of the year, which Freddie Mac said was continuing to weigh on market activity (Freddie Mac).

    Here is the mechanism most sellers miss. A 7% rate does not just shrink the pool of qualified buyers — it changes which buyers show up. Cash buyers and buyers with large equity from an out-of-state sale become disproportionately important, and they are also the most price-disciplined. In practice, homes in the $250,000 to $450,000 range where Fort Myers concentrates most of its stock face the tightest affordability squeeze, while higher-end and waterfront properties draw more equity-rich and cash buyers.

    The flip side is the move-up trap. If you sell and buy your next home in the same market with a mortgage, you trade a low pandemic-era rate for a higher one. For a meaningful share of Fort Myers owners, that arithmetic argues for holding — or for selling and renting briefly rather than buying immediately. Rate math, not market direction, is what stops most sellers in 2026.

    Freddie Mac's own forecast assumes house prices will grow about 1.3% over the next 12 months (Freddie Mac). Modest appreciation is still appreciation — but it does not come close to offsetting a high carrying cost while you wait.

    Which Fort Myers sellers should sell now — and who should hold?

    The decision turns on three variables, and almost every Lee County owner lands in one of four groups. Get honest about which group you are in before you list anything.

    Your situation

    What the market is telling you

    The move that usually works

    Bought before 2021, single-family home, no urgent need to move

    You still hold most of the boom gain and prices are drifting lower, not recovering

    List within the next two quarters and capture the equity before further drift

    Bought 2022–2023 and need to move within a year

    Likely near breakeven; waiting adds carrying costs without a credible rebound

    Price to the last 90 days of comps and budget for a modest concession

    Own a condo in an older building

    Lee County condo prices are down 24.8% from peak, and HOA and insurance costs keep rising

    Expect a longer timeline and heavier negotiation; get reserve and assessment documents ready early

    Plan to stay five-plus years

    Short-term price moves barely matter to you

    Hold, and use the soft market to negotiate your own next purchase

    Two rows deserve expansion, because they are where I see the most expensive mistakes.

    The condo column is the sharpest divergence in this market. ResiClub found Lee County condo prices spiked 72.1% during the boom and have since fallen 24.8%, leaving them up just 29.4% since March 2020 (ResiClub). That weakness traces to structural-safety rules passed after the 2021 Surfside collapse, which forced many Florida HOAs into special assessments and fee increases, and to tighter Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac underwriting on older condo buildings. Buyers now read association financials before they read your kitchen. If your building has deferred maintenance or a thin reserve account, that is priced in whether you disclose it or not.

    The pre-2021 single-family row is where the local experts are unusually direct. Denny Grimes put the case bluntly at Market Trends 2026: sellers who bought before the boom "still have equity on their porch," and he advised them not to wait for a comeback, adding that he does not expect one (Gulfshore Business). He expects buyer's-market conditions to persist for several years — which means the calendar is not your friend if you are selling anyway.

    What should you fix before you list?

    Less than most sellers think — but the right things matter enormously. In a market where buyers have alternatives, the homes that sell fastest are the ones with no unresolved insurance, roof, or association questions. Those objections kill Lee County deals; tired paint does not.

    Start with the roof and the four-point inspection, because both determine whether a buyer can even get insurance. Florida's property insurance market has improved, with several carriers filing rate decreases and Citizens lowering its average homeowners rate by 8.8%, but carriers still price heavily on roof age, construction type, and elevation (Wilcox Family Insurance). A home that a buyer can insure cheaply is worth measurably more than the identical home next door that requires a carrier hunt.

    Then get your documentation in order before the first showing: the wind mitigation report, the elevation certificate, the roof permit, and — for condos — the milestone inspection status and current reserve figures. Buyers in 2026 ask for these in the first week. Sellers who produce them in an hour rather than a week close at higher prices because they remove the fear premium.

    Finally, price against the last 90 days of closed sales in your specific subdivision, not against the Zillow estimate and not against what your neighbor listed for in 2022. A well-priced Fort Myers home still moves in roughly the metro average of about 65 days; an overpriced one sits, then sells for less than the correct price would have fetched on day one.

    The bottom line for late 2026

    If you own a Fort Myers single-family home bought before 2021, the evidence points one direction: sell while your equity is intact, because the forecast is for flat-to-slow appreciation and continued buyer's-market conditions for years. If you own a condo in an older building, prepare for a negotiation and a longer timeline. If you are staying put for five years or more, none of this should move you — and you get to shop the same soft market as a buyer.

    The mistake I see most often is not selling at the wrong moment. It is pricing to a memory. The market has told us clearly what it will pay for your home in November 2026, and it is still paying well for owners who bought before the boom. What it will not do is reward waiting for 2022 to return.

    ?Frequently Asked Questions4 questions
    1How long will my Fort Myers home take to sell right now?

    Roughly the average time it takes a Fort Myers home to go pending, per Zillow's September 2026 data. Homes priced correctly land near that figure; homes priced to 2022 comps routinely sit past 90 days and then sell below the original list price after two or three reductions.

    2Can I sell now but delay buying my next home?

    A hybrid approach works: sell now while equity is intact, then rent in the area for a few months while you shop. You avoid competing for your next home in the same tight window, you keep your sale proceeds liquid, and you gain negotiating leverage as a renter-turned-buyer in a market forecast to stay buyer-friendly for several years.

    3Will falling prices affect my ability to get a mortgage on my next home?

    Not usually. Loan limits are set by your loan-to-value ratio and credit profile, not the direction of the market. Where a declining market does bite is in appraisal risk — if a buyer's appraisal comes in under your contract price, you either renegotiate or the buyer covers the gap in cash. Recent comparable sales in your subdivision are the best defense against that outcome.

    4What actually kills deals in this market?

    Insurance availability, not price, is the deal-killer. An older roof or a building without current milestone inspection documentation can stall a contract for weeks while the buyer hunts for coverage. Resolve both before listing and you remove the most common reason Lee County contracts fall apart.

    B
    Brandon Lucas@brandonlucas
    Real Estate AdvisorRealty One Group MVP

    Want to connect with Brandon?

    Ask, follow, or jump into the discussion on this article.