For most buyers, a seller credit saves more money than an equal price reduction, because it cuts your cash to close almost dollar for dollar while a price cut only trims your payment a little each month. A price reduction can still win if your appraisal is a concern or you plan to keep the home for a long time. The right answer depends on your loan program, your cash and how long you plan to stay.
When an inspection turns up issues or a home has been sitting, sellers often agree to give something back. The question I get from buyers and agents is always the same. Should we ask for a lower price or a credit? Here is how I walk my clients through it.
One example, three ways
Let's use one illustrative Twin Cities purchase and the same $10,000 from the seller. The figures below are rounded examples that show how the math works.
Purchase price: $400,000
Conventional loan with 5% down
Seller agrees to give $10,000
Option 1: Price reduction to $390,000
Down payment drops from $20,000 to $19,500, so you keep $500 more in your pocket
Loan amount drops by $9,500
Monthly principal and interest drops by roughly $55 to $65, depending on your rate (estimate)
Option 2: $10,000 seller credit toward closing costs at $400,000
Down payment stays at $20,000
Up to $10,000 of your closing costs and prepaids are covered, as long as your actual costs are at least that much
Cash to close drops by up to $10,000
Monthly payment stays the same as the original price
Option 3: $10,000 seller credit used for a temporary 2/1 buydown
Your rate is 2% lower in year one and 1% lower in year two, then goes to the full note rate in year three
On a loan near $380,000, a 2/1 buydown often costs somewhere around $8,500 to $9,000, depending on the rate (estimate). Any leftover credit can usually go toward closing costs
Cash to close stays about the same as the original price
Payments are noticeably lower for the first two years, then rise to the full payment
What the comparison tells you
The difference between Option 1 and Option 2 is bigger than most people expect. The price reduction saves you about $500 at closing and roughly $60 a month. The seller credit saves you up to $10,000 at closing. At about $60 a month, it would take well over ten years for the price cut to catch up to the credit. That is why, for buyers who are watching every dollar of cash to close, the credit usually wins.
When a price reduction makes more sense
A lower price is not always the wrong ask. It can be the better choice when:
The appraisal might come in low. With a credit, the home still has to appraise at the full price. A price cut lowers the number the appraisal has to support.
You have plenty of cash and plan to stay a long time. If cash to close is not a problem and you expect to keep the home and loan for many years, the smaller loan keeps paying you back every month.
Your closing costs are smaller than the credit. A credit can only cover actual allowable costs. If your costs are lower than the credit, the extra is wasted unless it can be used another way.
You are close to a mortgage insurance or loan limit cutoff. A slightly lower price can sometimes move you into a better pricing tier.
When a temporary buydown makes sense
A seller paid buydown is about payment relief early on. It can make sense when you expect your income to rise, you want breathing room the first couple of years in a new home, or you want the lower payment while you settle in. The key is to qualify and budget for the full payment, because that is where the payment ends up in year three. I never want a client counting on a refinance to make the loan work. If rates fall and refinancing makes sense later, that is a bonus, not the plan.
On conventional loans, unused buydown funds are generally applied to your loan or used toward payments if you refinance or sell early, but the details depend on how the buydown is set up. If you are weighing a buydown against paying points for a permanently lower rate, read my article on why the lowest mortgage rate can cost you more. The same break even thinking applies.
Program limits on seller credits
Every loan program caps how much a seller can contribute. Asking for more than your program allows can force a renegotiation late in the deal, so check this before you write the offer.
Conventional (Fannie Mae), primary home or second home: 3% of value with less than 10% down, 6% with 10% to 25% down, 9% with more than 25% down (Fannie Mae Selling Guide, interested party contributions)
Conventional investment property: 2%
FHA: 6% of the sales price
USDA: 6%
VA loans let the seller pay normal closing costs, plus up to 4% of the home's reasonable value for items VA counts as concessions, such as a temporary buydown
Limits as of November 2026. Program rules change, so confirm the current limit for your loan with me before you write the offer.
In my example above, $10,000 on a $400,000 purchase with 5% down is 2.5% of the price, which fits under the 3% conventional limit. If the same buyer asked for $15,000, it would not.
A few practical tips for buyers and agents
Most of the work happens before you sign anything. Know your real closing costs, decide between a price cut and a credit using those numbers, and put the credit's purpose in writing so it survives underwriting.
Know your closing costs before you negotiate. I can give you an estimate so you ask for a credit you can actually use.
Write the credit correctly. Make sure the purchase agreement says what the credit is for, especially if part of it is going toward a buydown.
Think about the appraisal. If the price already feels stretched, a price cut may protect the deal better than a credit.
Run the numbers both ways. It takes me a few minutes to show you cash to close and payment side by side for each option.
1Can a seller credit pay my down payment?
No. Seller credits can cover allowable closing costs, prepaids and certain financing costs, but not your down payment.
2What happens if my closing costs are less than the seller credit?
The unused amount generally cannot be given to you as cash. That is why it helps to know your costs before you ask.
3Is a price reduction or seller credit better for my appraisal?
A price reduction lowers the value the appraisal needs to support. A credit keeps the price higher, so the home must still appraise at that number.
4Can a seller pay for a temporary buydown?
Yes, on most loan programs, as long as the total contribution stays within the program limit.
5Does a seller credit change my monthly payment?
A credit used for closing costs does not change your payment. A credit used for a buydown lowers it temporarily.
Want to see your numbers side by side?
If you are writing an offer or responding to an inspection in Andover or anywhere in the Twin Cities, call me before you counter. I will show you exactly what a price cut, a credit or a buydown does to your cash to close and payment, so you and your agent can ask for the option that actually helps you most. Call or text Brandon Peterson at 612-964-1371, or visit mortgagesbybrandon.com.
Brandon Peterson NMLS #302002 | Granite Bank NMLS# 405434, Equal Housing Lender, 11660 Theatre Drive N. Champlin, MN 55316. This is not a commitment to lend. Offers only per Minn. Stat. 47.206 sub 3&4. Loans subject to approval, terms subject to change. Member FDIC. nmlsconsumeraccess.org
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!