A low appraisal means the home you are buying came in below the agreed price, and the lender will only lend against that lower number. The deal is not dead, but you now have four paths forward, renegotiate the price, cover the gap with your own funds, ask the lender to reconsider the value, or walk away if your contract allows.
It happens more than you would think, so it helps to know your moves before the report lands. What happens next depends on your contract, your savings, and how much the seller wants to sell.
What is an appraisal and why does the lender order it?
An appraisal is a professional opinion of what a home is worth, done by a licensed appraiser who has to follow a set of rules in arriving at that value (CFPB). When you get a mortgage, the lender orders it because the home is the collateral for the loan, and they need a reliable number to know how much they can safely lend against it. In plain terms, the lender wants to make sure they are not lending more than the property is really worth.
The lender cannot steer the appraiser or push the number. The appraisal is meant to be an independent estimate, and the whole point is that nobody can pressure the person doing the work (CFPB). Getting an accurate read on value is one of the most important steps in the mortgage process, because a number that is too high or too low can create real problems down the road. The CFPB spells this out plainly: lenders typically require an appraisal when underwriting a mortgage, and it is an estimate of the value of the home.
So when the number comes back, the lender leans on it to size the loan. A solid appraisal keeps the deal moving. A low one changes the math for everyone involved.
Can you ask the lender to reconsider the value?
Yes, and this is often the smartest first move. Fannie Mae has a framework that requires lenders to review and respond to a borrower initiated reconsideration of value, which is when you ask the lender to take a second look at the appraisal because you think the value is off (Fannie Mae). The idea is simple, the appraiser may have missed a comparable sale, or may not have weighted a recent sale in the same neighborhood the way it deserved.
To make this work, you bring new evidence. A handful of recent sales that are genuinely similar to your home, ideally sales that closed around the same time. Your agent is the right person to help gather those. The appraiser is not supposed to be pushed into a number, but they can and should look at comparable sales you point to that they may not have seen or weighted correctly. The CFPB backs you up here too, lenders are required to send you a copy of the appraisal, so you can actually read how the value was reached before you push back (CFPB).
Can you renegotiate the price with the seller?
The low appraisal is strong evidence that the sale price sits above what the market will actually support, and the CFPB says you can often use it to negotiate a reduction in the price (CFPB). Picture a seller in Lansing who agreed to a price with a buyer, and now the appraised value comes in under that number. The buyer can go back and say the home appraised below the price, so can we meet at the appraised value?
This one works best when the seller wants to close. A seller who is ready to move, or who does not want the deal to fall apart and the home to sit on the market again, has a real reason to come down. Not every seller will agree, but the appraisal gives the buyer a factual anchor for the conversation instead of just a feeling that the price is too high.
What does covering the gap mean?
Covering the gap means you, the buyer, make up the difference between the appraised value and the agreed sale price with your own funds. The lender will only lend against the appraised number, so the cash above that has to come from somewhere else. For a buyer in Ann Arbor who found the right home and has the savings, this can be the fastest way to keep the deal alive.
But it is worth weighing carefully. Paying over the appraised value means you are bringing more of your own money into a home the market says is worth less than you are paying for it. That is your equity on day one, and it is a real tradeoff. The CFPB is blunt about the risk, it is very risky to purchase a home for more than the appraised value (CFPB). If you have room in your budget and the home is the one, some buyers decide the gap is worth it. Others look at that same risk and walk away.
Can you walk away if the contract allows?
Yes, if your purchase agreement includes an appraisal contingency. That clause says the deal can fall through if the home does not appraise at or above the agreed price, and depending on how it is written, it can let you back out without losing your earnest money. The CFPB says that if the seller will not reduce the price, you may want to cancel the sale, and it notes there may be costs depending on your contract (CFPB).
Before you decide anything, get a copy of your purchase agreement and find the appraisal contingency. Not every purchase agreement has one, and the wording can vary, so look for the clause that lets you back out if the home does not appraise at the agreed price, and ask your agent to point it out. Then talk it through with your agent, who knows how that clause reads in your specific contract and what it protects. Walking away when the numbers do not make sense is not a failure, it is protecting yourself from paying more than the home is worth.
What happens next for a buyer versus a seller?
What happens | Buyer | Seller |
|---|---|---|
Reconsideration | Ask the lender to recheck the value with better comparable sales | Share any sales the appraiser may have missed and stay flexible |
Renegotiating | Use the appraisal to ask for a lower price | Decide whether to come down to keep the deal together |
Covering the gap | Bring extra funds above the appraised value | Keep the agreed price while the buyer brings the difference |
Walking away | Cancel the deal if the appraisal contingency protects you | Return to the market and reset the asking price |
If you are the seller, your first move is the same as the buyer's, look at the report and decide if the value is fair. You can share comparable sales with the buyer's lender, come down to the appraised price to keep the deal alive, or hold firm and risk the buyer walking. The choice depends on how much you want to close and how long you can wait for the next offer.
The CFPB warns buyers it is risky to pay more than the home appraises for, so expect the buyer to push back on price (CFPB). Each path changes the balance between you and the other side, and none of them happen by accident. You have to start the conversation.
1How do I ask for a reconsideration after a low appraisal?
Get a copy of the appraisal from your lender first, since they are required to give it to you. Then share any recent comparable sales you or your agent found with the lender and ask them to review the value again, which Fannie Mae requires lenders to do for a borrower initiated reconsideration of value.
2Should I cover the gap when the appraisal is low?
Covering the gap means paying the difference between the appraised value and the sale price with your own funds, because the lender will only lend against the appraised number. It can save the deal, but the CFPB warns it is risky to pay more than the home appraises for.
3Can I walk away if the house appraises for less?
Yes, if your purchase agreement has an appraisal contingency that lets the deal fall through when the home does not appraise at the agreed price. That is why you should read your contract and talk with your agent before the appraisal even comes back, so you know exactly what you can walk away from.
A low appraisal does not have to sink your deal, but it does force a decision. The moves are the same whether you are buying or selling in Michigan, you either get the value rechecked, renegotiate the price, cover the difference, or step back if your contract protects you.
If an appraisal comes back short on your deal, talk it through with Derek Brickley at Gold Star Mortgage Financial Group. Derek can help you sort out which path fits your situation before you commit to any of them. What is your move when the number comes in low, negotiate, cover the gap, or walk?
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!