You cosigned a car for your kid.
They make every payment.
You have never paid a dime.
Then you apply for a mortgage and the lender says:
That car payment may count against you.
Welcome to one of the more frustrating parts of mortgage qualification.
If You Signed the Debt, You Are Obligated
Cosigning is not the same as being a reference.
You signed for the debt.
That means you are legally obligated if the other person stops paying.
And if that debt appears on your credit report, the lender has to determine whether the monthly payment belongs in your debt-to-income ratio (DTI).
But There May Be an Exception
Here is the good news.
Under current Fannie Mae conventional guidelines, certain non-mortgage debts paid by another person may potentially be excluded from your recurring monthly obligations.
That can include things such as:
auto loans
installment loans
student loans
revolving accounts
lease payments
But you have to prove someone else is actually paying the debt.
The Magic Number Is Usually 12 Months
For the Fannie Mae rule, the lender generally needs documentation showing the other person made the most recent 12 months of payments with no delinquencies.
That may mean providing canceled checks or bank statements from the person actually making the payments.
Simply saying:
“My daughter pays the car.”
does not document it.
Mortgage Debt Has an Extra Rule
If the debt is another mortgage, the requirements are more restrictive.
Fannie Mae generally requires the person making the payments to also be obligated on that mortgage debt, along with the required clean 12-month payment history.
So do not assume the rule for a cosigned car works exactly the same way for a mortgage.
Why This Matters So Much
Imagine you cosigned an auto loan with a:
$750 monthly payment.
If that payment has to be included in your DTI, it can materially change what you qualify for.
If it meets the applicable requirements to be excluded, your mortgage numbers may look completely different.
Same borrower.
Same credit report.
Different documentation.
Get the Proof Before You Need It
If you are planning to buy a home and someone else pays a debt that appears in your name, tell your mortgage broker early.
We may need a payment history.
And trying to reconstruct 12 months of somebody else’s bank records three days before underwriting clears the file is nobody’s idea of a good time.
The Better Question
Don’t ask:
“Why are you counting a payment I don’t make?”
Ask:
“Can we document that someone else has been paying it?”
That is what can change the underwriting answer.
About Jennifer Chicano
Jennifer Chicano, CMA™, is Your Loan Chic — a Certified Mortgage Advisor™ and mortgage broker helping buyers identify mortgage issues before they become closing problems. NMLS #1194079 | Zero Point Mortgage Services NMLS #1216108.
Schedule a Mortgage Strategy Call
Information is for educational purposes only and is not a commitment to lend, legal advice or financial advice. Debt treatment and documentation requirements vary by borrower, lender, loan program and underwriting findings.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!