VOCE
S
LoginStart Creating
Loading…
VOCE

The publishing platform for a more visible, trusted, and valuable professional presence.

VOH-chay is Italian for “voice.” Every expert has one worth hearing.

VOX is Latin for “voice,” too. He writes with you, answers your questions and shows you what to do next.

Platform

OwnershipDiscoveryMomentumExplore Content

Solutions

AuthorsBrandsAgenciesStart Writing

© VOCE. All rights reserved.

  • What We Do
  • Who We Are
  • Plans
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Legal
    End of article
    • 0 Likes
    • 0 Comments
    • 0 Questions
    • 0 Shares
    • 0 Views

    Discussion

    No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

    Q&A with the Author

    T
    Tres Miller

    @tresmiller

    Loan Consultant at loanDepot

    Tres The Magic Mortgage Lender Miller

    I’m Tres Miller, The Magic Mortgage Lender, a loan consultant at loanDepot and a U.S. Army veteran. I help buyers and homeowners in Utah, Salt Lake, and Davis counties compare mortgage options and understand what they’ll pay at closing and each month. I specialize in VA loans and reverse mortgages, and I also help first-time and move-up buyers. My approach is built on trust, transparency, and thoroughness. Consultations are available in English and American Sign Language (ASL). Explore Utah buyer guides and mortgage calculators at https://utahhomeownershipauthority.com/ Individual NMLS #217768 | loanDepot NMLS #174457

    10 Articles0 Followers
    More from Tres
    T
    Tres Miller
    @tresmiller
    Trending

    More from this Author

    Rent or Buy a Starter Home in Salt Lake County?

    Rent or Buy a Starter Home in Salt Lake County?

    Nov 21, 2026
    5 min
    00
    What Does a $500,000 Utah Home Cost Per Month?

    What Does a $500,000 Utah Home Cost Per Month?

    Nov 20, 2026
    5 min
    50
    Price Cut or Seller Credit? Using $10,000 in Salt Lake City

    Price Cut or Seller Credit? Using $10,000 in Salt Lake City

    Nov 19, 2026
    5 min
    60
    View all 6 articles from Tres →
    1. Read
    2. Topics
    3. Real Estate
    4. mortgage
    5. How to Choose a Mortgage Lender: 10 Things to Compare
    12 min
    How to Choose a Mortgage Lender: 10 Things to Compare

    Photo by Chandler Cruttenden on Unsplash

    Real Estate

    How to Choose a Mortgage Lender: 10 Things to Compare

    TTres Miller
    November 22, 2026

    It's 7:40 on a Friday night. You've just toured a home in Sandy that checks the boxes. Your agent is ready to write the offer, but you want to know what an extra $10,000 would do to your monthly payment. You text your lender.

    Earlier that day, one lender quoted a lower rate. Now you also need a clear answer while there's still time to decide. That's why I'd look at both what each lender is offering and how they help me make decisions. Here are the 10 things I'd check.

    I'm a loan consultant in Orem, and I've watched buyers pick a lender on rate alone, then spend six weeks chasing that lender for updates. The rate is one line on the estimate. The rest of the estimate, and the person who answers your texts, decide how the next 45 days go. This guide takes about 20 minutes of reading and one afternoon of phone calls with each lender.

    Key Takeaways

    • Get two written Loan Estimates built from the same property, down payment, loan type, term, and lock period. The CFPB calls the Loan Estimate a standardized form that lays out the details of a loan offer.
    • A lower rate often costs money upfront in discount points. Compare the monthly savings against what you pay for it over the years you plan to keep the loan.
    • Watch how each lender handles ordinary days before you're under contract. Follow-through during preapproval predicts follow-through during underwriting.
    • Ask who your agent can reach on a Saturday evening, and who calls you first when cash to close or the closing date might move.
    Pro Tip

    Prerequisites before you start comparing: a property address or price range, your down payment amount, the loan type and term you want (30-year fixed is the usual starting point), a target closing date, and a lock period long enough to cover it. Time needed: about 30 minutes per lender on the phone plus an afternoon to compare. Cost: getting Loan Estimates is free. Skill level: none, but ask each lender to put the numbers in writing.

    Step 1: Get both quotes built on the same loan

    Ask both lenders to price the same property, down payment, loan type, and term on the same day. The CFPB describes the Loan Estimate as a standardized form that tells you the important details of a loan offer (CFPB). It also warns that rates can change daily, so a gap between two estimates issued on different days may just be the market moving (CFPB).

    Confirm whether each rate is locked and when the lock expires. The CFPB's own rate examples assume a 60-day lock (CFPB), and a shorter lock can price differently.

    Ask: Can you quote the same loan with a lock period that covers my closing date?

    Success check. You're holding two Loan Estimates with matching loan amounts, terms, and lock periods, so every difference between them is real.

    Step 2: Price the lower rate against what it costs upfront

    A lower rate usually comes with discount points, which are fees paid at closing to buy the rate down. Compare the monthly savings against the upfront cost over the years you expect to keep the loan, not just the first payment.

    Run the arithmetic before you decide. Ask each lender for the monthly payment with points and without, subtract the smaller from the larger, and divide the upfront cost by that monthly difference. The result is your break-even month. The CFPB points out that borrowers keep a mortgage for about five years on average, which is why its comparison tool is built around a five-year cost of borrowing (CFPB). Sell or refinance before your break-even month and the higher rate with no points was the better deal.

    Success check. You can name the break-even month for each offer and say how long you plan to stay in the home.

    Step 3: Walk the full payment and cash to close

    Have each lender walk you through taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance, and any HOA dues you'd pay separately. Then look at cash to close, which combines the down payment, fees, prepaids, and credits. The CFPB's Loan Estimate explainer flags the lines worth checking, including the total monthly payment, whether taxes and insurance sit outside escrow, and whether you have enough cash on hand (CFPB).

    Compare only the numbers the lender controls. If one estimate shows much lower taxes or insurance, that loan is not cheaper, since lenders don't set those costs (CFPB). Buyers also routinely underestimate the full monthly cost once taxes, insurance, HOA dues, utilities, and maintenance land in the same budget (Core Bank).

    Ask: What accounts for the difference between these two estimates?

    Success check. Both cash-to-close totals are within a few hundred dollars of each other, or you know which line explains the gap.

    Step 4: Test whether they remember what matters to you

    Suppose you tell a lender you want $20,000 left in savings after closing. A week later you send a listing near the top of your budget. The lender worth keeping runs the numbers and tells you what it does to that $20,000.

    The CFPB lists your comfort with the loan officer's ability to answer your questions as one of the factors in choosing a lender, right alongside the cost of the loan (CFPB). A lender who quotes a payment without asking about your savings, timeline, or comfort level has skipped the part that makes the quote useful.

    Ask: Based on what I've told you, what would you help me watch for as I shop?

    Success check. The lender repeats your number back to you without being reminded of it.

    Step 5: Watch whether they call when they say they will

    If a lender says they'll call by four, notice what happens at four. Even a short call saying they're still waiting on an answer tells you when to expect an update. Run this test during preapproval, when the stakes are low and you can see how they handle an ordinary day.

    This is where most lender comparisons quietly get decided. A lender who is slow to respond or inconsistent with updates before you are officially in the process usually does not improve later, and homebuying moves quickly enough that delays cost everyone (CrossCountry Mortgage).

    Ask: If you need more time to get an answer, when will you check back with me?

    Success check. You have two lenders who hit the callback times they named, or one clear winner.

    Step 6: Find out who answers on a Saturday night

    If your agent and you are writing an offer on Saturday evening, you may need a payment estimate or an updated preapproval letter within the hour. Ask who can help and when.

    A useful reply sounds like this: I saw your text, send me the address and offer price, and I'll have the numbers by eight. That answer gives your agent something to work with. Bankrate's guidance is blunt about the alternative, noting that you can switch lenders when communication is poor early on, though waiting too long can cost fees or push closing (Bankrate).

    Ask: If you're unavailable on a Saturday evening, who can my agent and I reach?

    Success check. You have a name and a phone number for after-hours, not just a promise of availability.

    Step 7: Ask what they actually verified for preapproval

    Ask what the lender verified and what still needs review. If your down payment includes a gift or your income varies by season or commission, raise it early rather than at underwriting.

    Lenders re-check credit, employment, and finances before closing, and routine moves like opening a car loan, changing jobs, or shuffling money between accounts can stall or sink an approval (Core Bank). A lender who names the specific documents they reviewed is telling you how much of your file has already been checked. A lender who guarantees approval before seeing your paperwork is telling you something else (CrossCountry Mortgage).

    Ask: What have you already verified, and what could still affect my approval?

    Success check. You can name the two or three items still outstanding, and the lender told you without being pushed.

    Step 8: Confirm how they keep you and your agent informed

    Once you're under contract, ask who updates you after the appraisal and during underwriting. You want to know when you'll hear from the lender, who your agent can contact about deadlines, and whether you're waiting on the lender or they're waiting on you.

    This is the point where vague fees and shifting numbers get expensive. If estimated fees, payments, or cash to close keep moving and nobody explains why, that creates confusion at exactly the moment you have the least room for it (CrossCountry Mortgage).

    Ask: Who will update us, and when should we expect the next update?

    Success check. You have a named contact and a stated cadence, such as a Monday update until closing.

    Step 9: Find out who calls first when something changes

    If the lender learns on Tuesday that your cash to close might rise or the closing date could slip, you want a call Tuesday. Ask for a plain-English explanation of what changed, what options you have, and who handles the next step.

    Timing matters because you may have already booked movers or given notice on your rental. The CFPB expects a lender to explain any significant change in closing costs, and its Closing Disclosure explainer walks through what to ask when a number has moved (CFPB).

    Ask: If my costs or closing date could change, who will call me and walk me through it?

    Success check. The lender describes a process for notifying you, not just a promise to do it.

    Step 10: Review the final numbers together before you sign

    Before signing, ask someone at the lender to go through the Closing Disclosure with you. Lenders must provide it three business days before your scheduled closing, and the CFPB's explainer says to use those days to resolve problems (CFPB).

    Check that the loan term, loan amount, interest rate, total monthly payment, closing costs, and cash to close match your most recent Loan Estimate. If the rate is not what you locked, ask why. If cash to close rose, ask which line moved.

    Ask: Will we review the final figures together before I sign?

    Success check. Every number on the Closing Disclosure traces back to an explanation you already heard.

    What if the lender I trust costs more?

    Show them the competing Loan Estimate and ask them to explain the difference or match it. The CFPB notes that your best bargaining chip is usually having other lenders' estimates in hand, and that negotiating works best in a short window after you have a signed purchase contract (CFPB).

    If a gap remains, put a dollar figure on it. A few hundred dollars over five years is usually worth better communication. A few thousand changes the math.

    A house near a mountain ridge in Utah

    If you're weighing two quotes or want to talk through the numbers on a specific Utah home, visit Utah Homeownership Authority for buyer guides, mortgage calculators, or a conversation about your options.

    Tres Miller · The Magic Mortgage Lender · Loan Consultant at loanDepot · Individual NMLS #217768 · loanDepot NMLS #174457. Rates and payments are illustrative. Actual terms vary by borrower, property, and loan program.

    ?Frequently Asked Questions5 questions
    1One lender came back higher after I asked them to match. Now what?

    Show them the other estimate and ask them to match it. The CFPB notes that having estimates from other lenders is usually your strongest negotiating position, and that the window right after you sign a purchase contract is the best time to use it. If the gap holds, decide whether the difference in dollars is worth the difference in service.

    2My payment went up between preapproval and the Loan Estimate. Is that normal?

    Do not assume it is final. Lenders can reprice, especially when the market moves. Ask what changed, whether a different lock period or fewer points brings the payment back in line, and what it does to cash to close before you decide.

    3A third lender quoted lower than both. Should I switch?

    Ask for an estimate on the same property, loan amount, term, and lock period before you treat it as comparable. If the lower payment comes from a different down payment or a shorter lock, you are comparing two different loans, not two lenders.

    4How many Loan Estimates do I actually need?

    Two is enough to see how each lender handles questions and deadlines, but the CFPB recommends comparing at least three loan offers from different lenders. A third estimate gives you a second negotiating lever and a backup if one lender cannot close on time.

    5Can I still change lenders after my offer is accepted?

    Nothing you have signed with a lender obligates you to close with them. If communication is poor early, switching is reasonable, though waiting too long can cost fees or push your closing date. Make the call before you are deep into underwriting.

    T
    Tres Miller@tresmiller
    Loan Consultant at loanDepotTres The Magic Mortgage Lender Miller

    Want to connect with Tres?

    Ask, follow, or jump into the discussion on this article.